MovieChat Forums > Fixer Upper (2013) Discussion > Coffee House couple in the craftsman

Coffee House couple in the craftsman

posted 8 years ago by dolphin91115
9 replies | jump to latest

I don't mean to sound like a hater, but is it just me or did they completely mess up that house? I hate what they did to that fireplace, demoing on the surrounding walls. I know it had already been resurfaced by a previous owner, in a way not authentic to that type of architecture. But the exposed brick looked horrible.

Also, the open shelving in the kitchen replaced what I thought were beautiful cabinets.

Also, the cased archway could have also been in a more "craftsman" type of style with columns and bookshelves on the bottom.

I don't mean to pick, but am I the only one who agrees that Chip and Joanna messed up that house? On the bright side, I did like the windows that the couple had picked out.

[–] LadyMarysHat 8 years ago

It's not the only house she's messed up royally. One girl, the single foster mom, picked a darling little 40's cottage nestled away in a quiet neighborhood but Joanna treated it like a downtown loft. She has a pathological need to tear down walls. I think if she could get away with it she'd have an open bedroom plan. I would NEVER use her services because it seems to me she doesn't allow the clients any input.

[–] dolphin91115 8 years ago

I think she is only good at updating generic 1950s and 1960s ranch style homes that didn't have much character to begin with, as well as maybe updating a 1990s build. I feel like she would ruin homes with good bones, such as craftsman, victorians, mid-century moderns, etc.

On today's episode (not sure if it was a rerun), she showed the young single man a mid-century modern and than her design included adding windows that would completely throw off the architecture. It was cringeworthy. Thankfully, he chose a ranch style home that are a dime a dozen on the show and here in Texas.

[–] LadyMarysHat 8 years ago

She HAS ruined homes with good bones. See 40's cottage I mentioned above, but early on there was also a 1930's Craftsman?, I believe, where she took out the original windows just so she could have brand new windows installed lower on the wall [so the owner could look out as he sat at his desk SMH!!] which meant demolishing part of the original brick outer wall etc. It was an expensive disaster that cost the homeowners a much needed master bath re-do. Then there was the 100 year old shotgun house done up with metal porch railings and ultra modern interior. OY. Vey. The couple wanted to preserve a piece of Waco history--SCRATCH THAT.

[–] Planet-38 8 years ago

What does it matter if the viewers don't agree with what is done to the homes if the buyer is pleased?

I can't understand why people don't understand that interior designers are chosen based on their reputations and previous work. The people that select the Gaines are doing so because they like the work they have done in the past. What difference does it make that those at home don't like the results or think they are repetitive. That is what the home buyer is seeking - Chips ability to renovate the structure and Jo's ability to renovate the interior.

The primary appeal of the show to viewers seems to be the personalities that are the stars. If you don't like anything about the show, why watch it?

"Arguing with idiots is like trying to play chess with a pigeon..."

[–] dolphin91115 8 years ago

Jeesh step away from the computer and calm yourself down. Can't I enjoy the show without loving every single renovation? I like the show and like many of Joanna's designs, but that doesn't mean I have to fanboy/fangirl out. She has her own style that works with some properties and not-so-much others.

[–] Planet-38 8 years ago

Not sure what you are referring to regarding "calm yourself down" since I, like you was just expressing my opinion. But, live and let...

"Arguing with idiots is like trying to play chess with a pigeon..."

[–] Tammyleighbarrett 8 years ago

Everyone has opinions. I bet we could find a ton of people who love what they do!!!
Just like that phrase... Opinions are like @@@holes, every one has one!!!

[–] Low_Rent 8 years ago

I recently watched an episode (I can't remember which one, unfortunately) that the reno didn't include gutters on the front of the house and the roof sloped towards the front. Joanna put a cheap looking awning over the door that looked like it was made out of flimsy material. Like a tarp or canvas. All that rain water will be falling against the foundation every time it rains.

Kiss my Converse! - Sho'nuff: The Shogun of Harlem.

[–] liscarkat (16768) 2 years ago

They seem to specialize in turning every house into a generic trend showroom. They all end up looking about the same. They have little or no knowledge of or interest in preserving original architectural styles.