MovieChat Forums > Truth (2015) Discussion > Truth: A Terrible, Terrible Movie About ...

Truth: A Terrible, Terrible Movie About Journalism (The Atlantic)


If you google Truth (2015), this is one of the first results. It's appalling that many critics rated it highly.

The fake documents from 1973 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killian_documents_controversy
https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2015/10/truth-a-terrible-terrible-movie-about-journalism/412036/

The film concerns 60 Minutes’s 2004 pre-election reporting on George W. Bush’s service in the Texas Air National Guard. Two documents central to the news program’s contention that Bush was granted preferential treatment were subsequently revealed to be almost certainly fraudulent. This error ultimately resulted in the retirement from CBS of Dan Rather (played here with likable understatement by Robert Redford) and the firing of Mapes and others. It’s in the midst of her “conspiracy theory” speech that Mapes suggests that the fraudulent documents were a cunning ploy by pro-Bush forces—immaculately sophisticated in some respects, but childishly certain to be recognized as fake in others—intended to discredit further reporting into his military record. Could this be true? Stranger things have happened, I suppose. But it’s pretty much the definition of a conspiracy theory.

reply