MovieChat Forums > Still Alice (2015) Discussion > Pills scene is unrealistic (spoilers)

Pills scene is unrealistic (spoilers)


If Alice really forgot what she was supposed to do every time she went upstairs, why did she keep remembering she was watching a video with instructions the minute before? And then, the last time when she comes back and decides to grab the laptop, why did she remember she had just gone upstairs looking for something but forgetting what it was?


People with advanced Alzheimer's (as Alice is supposed to be at this stage) usually forget what they were doing altogether, instead of just forgetting the last step and going back to the previous one. Therefore, once upstairs she would have rather gotten distracted and started doing something else, forgetting about the computer and the video entirely.

reply

I'm going to play the "artistic license" card here. I believe at this point, the film makers were going more for the emotional tension and less for the authenticity. In order to suspend disbelief, I reason that Alice's video to herself held some special power for Alice, which kept drawing her back to the video instead of wandering off the the next distraction. On some level, she knew the instructions in this video were of supreme importance.

reply

She was having a good day. She was making herself some tea and talking on the laptop with her daughter.

www.freerice.com

reply

Agreed, came here to say the same thing.

reply