The original from 1977 could have been re-issued instead. Why remake this.
Why not remake this? No remake is exact (although, The Birdcage was played way too similarly to Les Cages aux Folles and fell short, in my opinion) and each director brings something new to the interpretation of an existing story. You might call all of those productions of Shakespeare "remakes". Just because a story has been translated into film once does not mean it's a done deal. Would you prefer that many of today's movies not have been made and the old black and white version or even the silent film versions be reissued instead? That's squashing creativity. I've noted a couple of remakes of Incredible Journey and both were good and interesting, about three versions of The Parent Trap and, again, they were all interesting. I favor some versions of Little Women over others, but still enjoy seeing them retold different ways. There's A Christmas Carol and The Miracle on 34th Street told and retold different ways. "Remaking" films, plays, and stories, is a time honored craft. I would call it "retelling" instead.
reply
share