MovieChat Forums > Beauty and the Beast (2017) Discussion > Maybe Beauty should have been played by ...

Maybe Beauty should have been played by a beautiful girl


I know cuckered harry potter fans think this ugly hypocritical bitch who looks like a guy is "cute", but it's hypocritical in every way that they chose her. First, in real life she only dates super hot guys so why is she in this movie that makes a completely different statement, and second - she's ugly. Unless she's playing the beast, this won't work.

reply

what the hell? Who she dates in true life is about the very last thing on earth that matters to anyone besides you.

She is an actress. On what planet has it been mandated that the role one takes on should mirror their real life.... If anything, its exactly the opposite.

And THEN.... THEN, you dare speak about the sanctity of the story, with the seeing past physical imperfections, all the while calling HER ugly.... Ironic much? If you are on a message board, anonymously calling someone ugly, then guess what? You no longer allowed to judge someone else's superficiality.

reply

I agree to an extent. Emma is attractive in her own way, but she's no way pretty enough to be "the most beautiful girl in town." She's always got that stank face.

Cast in point:
https://lovelace-media.imgix.net/uploads/1334/35ff1940-8358-0134-ce12-0aec1efe63a9.jpg

And her profile and caveman brow is just unfortunate:
http://static2.thisisinsider.com/image/581cbdce6acfdb1e008b4601-1200/the-horns-are-a-lot-bigger-than-in-the-animated-version-while-his-mane-looks-more-like-hair-than-fur.jpg

Granted, Emma can appear beautiful from certain angles and lighting, but Belle should be lovely at all times.


.

reply

Her profile is lovely. I don't know what you're talking about, it being "unfortunate". She and Judy Garland have the best profiles I've ever seen.

reply

Ok, you guys are being sexist here, expecting Belle to be beautiful at all times. Not everything has to go your way. In fact look at this link.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BMfFp9IAoZy/

And quoting from a certain animated film, life isn't some cartoon musical where you sing a little song and your insipid dreams magically come true! So. Let. It. Go.

reply

Emma Watson is gorgeous. Are you high?

reply

Exactly, thank you.

reply

I've said it before: Emma Watson is pretty, but not beautiful. And it helps, because her Belle has a charm and grace that comes from her being a smart and caring lady, and doesn't need to be played by someone stunning like Emma Stone or Rachel Weisz.

07/08/06... 786... the sentinel of Allah has arrived.

reply

[deleted]

You're beyond saving but seek out help anyways at your closest mental institution.

You don't have to be a Harry Potter fan to think she's beautiful.

reply