Plot hole?


Why did Abbot get killed by the C4 explosive? The aliens clearly see the future so knew the bomb was planted from the outset. This is proven by the fact that one of the Aliens shoves both Dr. Banks and Ian down the hatch before the bomb goes off. Usually having foreknowledge of an event comes in handy when it comes to saving your own life.

reply

The movie did fail to explain that the ability to see the future is incompatible with free will. You can see the future, precisely because you won't change it. Free will is meaningful for humans because we think in a sequential way. The aliens think in a simultaneous way, they enact the future, they don't change it.

reply

Ok, but they did change the "future" by not letting Amy Adams and Jeremy Renner die from the explosion. Why couldn't they do the same for Abbot?

reply

That's quite an interesting question. I don't think the aliens change the future, they knew that saving them would result in Abbott's death. The aliens are able to see the future precisely because they won't change it.

reply