MovieChat Forums > Pussy Riot: A Punk Prayer (2013) Discussion > This trial had NOTHING TO DO WITH artist...

This trial had NOTHING TO DO WITH artistic censorship


There's this myth that Pussy Riot's dilemma in this documentary is an example of the crosshairs of art vs. censorship. No, it's not because they weren't censored. The arrest & trial of three of its main members -- Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, Maria Alyokhina and Yekaterina Samutsevich -- was FOR their offensive protest “performance” at a Moscow cathedral in 2012 wherein they were charged with hooliganism motivated by enmity (hatred) toward a religious group and disturbing the social order.

I have an obvious message for these three women (aged 22, 23 and 29 respectively at the time of the events): If you don’t want to go to jail don’t enact hateful criminal protests. Let me put it this way: What if several conservative Christians visited whatever dive they “perform” at and carried out a mocking, hostile rant against them and their ilk? They’d be incensed and immediately put a stop to it, not to mention press charges to prevent it from happening again.

Speaking of “performing,” the girls’ music is laughably trite punk ditties. Separated from the political hype, their cacophonies wouldn’t register even a blip on the punk/rock/metal barometer.

In the film, a couple of the females are asked what they’re protesting against and one of them says they’re objecting to the (supposed) Russian expectation of women to have babies and do little else in society (notice that she was NOT protesting against artistic censorship). In reply, two things need to be pointed out: (1.) No one in Russia was forcing her or anyone else to have babies and (2.) the movie itself shows women in all kinds of significant professions in Russia, including two judges, a prominent lawyer and police officers. It’s a classic case of being rebels without a cause. If they don’t like Putin, fine, vote against him and look into becoming a politician. If they don’t like the conservative sway in current Russian culture, then they should do their part to respectfully influence society to their point of view, which would include offering a POSITIVE EXAMPLE of their (supposedly superior) belief system.

Instead, these women opted for outrageous acts in their 3-year protest against the Russian government, culminating in the sacrilegious incident at the Russian Orthodox cathedral. Examples of their protests include: Sticking freakin' poultry up their nether regions in supermarkets, spray-painting vulgar graffiti on bridges, staging an unbelievable public orgy at a museum when Nadya was eight-months pregnant, which is actually shown in the movie for like 10 seconds (two clips). Seriously? In response to the girls' arrest, Putin expressed “I’m surprised they weren’t apprehended prior to this.” So am I. Russia is obviously a very generous society.

The flick is evenhanded in that it lacks a biased narration and simply shows the actual footage, translating the Russian verbiage into English, with a smattering of interviews with parents, husbands and whoever. It’s a fascinating documentary in that it reveals modern Russian culture, its predominant values and lunatic fringe. I was surprised to observe that the elder disciples of the Russian Orthodox Church resemble formidable American bikers more than anything else.

Unfortunately, the film foolishly sides with the girls. Which is baffling since anyone with a modicum of common sense can see that they got precisely what their doofus behavior deserved. If a group of conservatives in American did what these women did, but enacted toward liberal people & institutions (e.g. a prominent gay nightclub), they’d be lambasted by the lamestream media and imprisoned for years for hooligan hate crimes. Of course loony libertines are notorious for their hypocritical double standards.

reply

Spot-on. These girls are just Russian version of the rabid far-leftists that can be found all over the west. Of course, they screech and whine about oppression now, but when they become part of the mainstream and overtake the academic institutions they become 10 times as opressive and intolerant.

reply

Yeah, like currently in the USA, lol.

reply