MovieChat Forums > Dead Space 3 (2013) Discussion > Dead Space 3 The Worst of the Trilogy?

Dead Space 3 The Worst of the Trilogy?


I feel like there's too much action instead of survival horror. I love the game though, it just doesn't compare to the other 2. I shouldn't be shooting other people at all in a Dead Space game.
Dead Space = John Carpenter
Dead Space 2 = David Fincher
Dead Space 3 = Michael Bay

reply

I definitely agree. It destroyed all subtlety and originality the first two games had.

reply

DS3 is most definitely the worst of the trilogy. But I don't think it's "bad" in and of itself. Most of the flaws can be pretty much ignored.

reply

Horrible and boring game. Nothing but waves of boring enemies and crappy puzzles in between.

reply

Agreed, worst in the series, but still not a bad game. I enjoyed it, until about the last two chapters when I just wanted to get it over with.

As for being scary, I thought most of the parts in space was scary, but barely anything on the planet was.
However, I also only thought the first and second game was ay scary in the beginning.

I like the Dead Space series because it mixes action with horror really well.



There is no good or evil, only different opinions

reply

I agree. While DS3 was the worst of the bunch, it was definitely not a bad game. I didn't really mind the human enemies that much at all, but I really hated how nearly every single room you entered on the ice planet had wave after wave after wave of enemies.. The space part of the game was well made, but being on the planet was just a damn chore although it looked pretty.

Fear not the darkness, but welcome its embrace.

reply

DS 3 is my favorite in the series (just my opinion)

reply

By far. It has a few good moments but is pretty weak overall. They tried to inject way too much combat which the clunky controls can't really accommodate, and the atmosphere and pacing were awful compared to the other two. I did like the weapon system, and like how they handled ammo.

I would rank them like this:
Dead Space 1: 8
Dead Space 2: 9
Dead Space 3: 6.5

reply

I prefer the "Alien" comparison.

Dead Space = Alien
Dead Space 2 = Aliens
Dead Space 3 = Alien: Resurrection

-------------------------------
Defenseless = Safe

reply

I liked DS3 better the first play through but after my 2nd and 3rd I realized I liked it the least. Weapon crafting is nice but it seemed lazy at the end with all the backtracking and the ending was just weird. No more rappelling!

I still like part 2 the best.

reply

The worst by far, no argument about it.

Dead Space - 8/10
Dead Space 2 - 9/10
Dead Space 3 - 6/10

reply