this garbage gets made....


while real fantasy like wheel of time, runelords, mistborn and others gets nothing....

i guess it was all about economics... the cgi was minimal and only bascialy appeared in the final fight and afew small cheap bits like seeing miss peregrin and the hollow in the beginning for 4 seconds.......

reply

ive watched 15 mins of max steel, one of the worst movies of the years that never should of been made, and the first 15 mins are already better than the entire miss perigrans movies............


why does jake and his grandpas power only apply to a freak science experiment that happened decades after his granpa was born>????????


and please dont say "well book 3 explains it better".. its a film... thereofre i should have to read an entire series just to understand one poorly made film....


damn Tim Burton..... how the mighty have fallen....

reply

why does jake and his grandpas power only apply to a freak science experiment that happened decades after his granpa was born>????????


It's a metaphor.


"You couldn't be much further from the truth" - several

reply

for nonsensical plot.........

just because its a metaphor.... doesnt make it good... sorry champ

reply

You asked why and I gave you an answer. Now you say you don't like the metaphor. Does that mean you understand it?

reply

Does that mean you understand it?


I don't. Care to explain the metaphor?

reply

"Each of the characters has a slight symbolic meaning to them that I always tried to relate to."

http://directconversations.com/2016/09/28/interview-tim-burton-finds-happy-haunt-miss-peregrines-home-peculiar-children


"You couldn't be much further from the truth" - several

reply

That's just a link to an interview.

Surely you can sum up this metaphor or at least quote which part is relevant?

reply

What is your exact question?

reply

You said it was a metaphor. A metaphor for what?

reply

Yeah but what? Jack, the grandpa ?

"You couldn't be much further from the truth" - several

reply

Riiiight....yeah i figured you didn't know wtf you were talking about. Thanks for confirming it.

reply

Don't be so rude but let me know which character you are talking about and I will try to explain what the character symbolises.

reply

I'm going to pass but thanks for all your help.

reply

Ok I'll tell you one for free / the girl with powers to enlarge a carrot = LOL guess what

reply

and please dont say "well book 3 explains it better".. its a film... thereofre i should have to read an entire series just to understand one poorly made film....


I agree with this so much. I've read all 3 books. This movie ruined them in so many ways, one of them being that there were so many things I knew would make no sense to me if I had not read the books.

On the other hand, there were just as many moments that made no sense BECAUSE I had read the books, and the movie broke so many of the book-established rules. A movie adaptation, in my opinion, should both complement the source material AND work as a stand-alone piece.

reply

i meant shouldnt but im glad you didnt nitpick!

hmm well i can relate lots of my favorite books havent translated fully over to screen form.


On the other hand, there were just as many moments that made no sense BECAUSE I had read the books, and the movie broke so many of the book-established rules. A movie adaptation, in my opinion, should both complement the source material AND work as a stand-alone piece.


absolutely. that is why some of the prequel (star wars) fans bots are the. Some actually tell you to read other books or watch clone wars tv show for it to make sense..

reply

I never even questioned that and I've read the book. Just the first one. My guess is sheet the monsters were made, the peculiar gene evolved to fight them? I know. Total stretch. Your one question kind of throws off the whole premise.

reply

You always get one numptie on a forum don't you.. i wonder which rival studio you're working for? lol

For a start we're seeing a story, The grandfather is telling his grandson a story and we're seeing that story, what the grandson is imagining. I dunno if you ever had kids or made up a bedtime story for them.. this is one of those.

There powers were to see those creatures which hunted the children, those creatures were not created during the science experiment that was a different things altogether i think.

reply

noo it wasnt different altogehter.... jake even talks about the "long armed slender creatures", which are the hollows... which were created in the experiment and were peculiars who engaged in the experiemnet for ever lasting life...

reply

Agree. Emma was just the girl from the supermarket.

reply

And this garbage goes on my ignore list

reply

awwww a crybaby fanbot cultists. literally the scourge of imdb...

reply

Best movie this year and there wasn't many.

reply

Bascialy?

reply

Does anyone agree resources ought to be put into filming Ray Bradbury's works right...or just me?

reply