Will's cellmate


Was that his dad?

reply

Yeah it was. Like the guard said, some people go a little looney after awhile. I was too focused on the other storylines and it completely flew over my head until the last scenes where I saw the "cell mate" in the fishing picture. Had to go watch it again to really understand what they talked about. As *beep* as Will's representation of his father is, he made some points about Will's personality that I had noted for the past few years. Plus, I really loved the quote about fishing.

reply

I didn't pick up on this until I saw the picture LOL.

reply

Anyone that says otherwise is lying

reply

Twice he said something he shouldn't have known. On the first I thought he was a plant to get the name. But on the second, 'mission to civilize', I realized he was imaginary. Didn't get it was his dad until the picture but I should have.

---
"Were you in Virginia?"
"That's beside the point."

reply

My guard was raised when the cellmate mentioned "mission to civilize". At first I thought the cellmate was an undercover plant from the FBI to get his source, then when he knew things he shouldn't and didn't interact with anyone but Will I figured he was imaginary. Also I highly doubt they would put a violent felon with 3 strikes in the same cell as a famous journalist in for contempt. Even OJ got his own cell..

http://www.facebook.com/bringbacklaworder

reply

I thought the same!

reply

Me too. Also given his, "tell me the name of your source" plan earlier.

When I'm gone I would like something to be named after me. A psychiatric disorder, for example.

reply

He was imagining what his father would say to him

reply

Exactly...

reply

Wow, that's really clever. I was sleepy last night and missed that. I'll have to watch it again now.

reply

From the start, he either had to be a plant (an agent) to get him to spill the source's name, or his subconscious, having a dialog with himself. It's fitting that he would look like, have the background of, and present the views of his father. It was well handled, kept us guessing until we got a closeup of the photo.

reply

When he mentioned the civilized line that Will knew he hadn't mentioned I thought he was an agent too

reply

Yes. Will was alone in his cell and the image of his father was kind of a day dream.

reply

I watched this On Demand and luckily following the episode is a summary from Aaron Sorkin. I was confused by the picture Will had on the wall, and wouldn't have known the cellmate represented his dad.

reply

I like some of Sorkin's writing but others I really dislike. When the cellmate dialogue started, I began thinking what terrible writing this was since I didn't expect a new cellmate dialogue to be anything like this. Then at the end when I saw the picture of Will and his dad, I felt like "Oh man. There were clues from the beginning and I can't believed I missed it."

Great episode.

reply

Yes,
I think it was Sorkin's tribute to Stanley Kubrick.

Remember the very end of The Shining, the camera focussing on the picture from decades before with Jack Nicholson in it.

reply

It took me a while before the final reveal of the photo of Will and his father to figure out that Will’s cellmate was just Will’s imagination working overtime after 52 days in solitary confinement. But the clues were there. The conversations between the two of them were so well written that I figured that Will’s cellmate was more than just someone who’d been conveniently placed in Will’s jail cell.

My first reaction after seeing the final reveal was that Aaron Sorkin and/or Paul Lieberstein (the episode's director) might be fans of Field of Dreams. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b_wnD6jxREU But your reference to a tribute to Stanley Kubrick with a reference to the final scene of The Shining also hits home. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-fN-Xjpd-qE

If it is what it is, what is it?

reply

yep his dad, was great seeing will talk about his childhood and address all the stuff I've always noticed about him and how he treats others

"the day I tried to live, I learned that I was alive"

reply

I didn't figure it out until I heard Aaron Sorkin in the Behind the Episode clip afterwards. (Didn't notice the rolled-up bed!) As I was listening to it, I thought the cellmate's dialogue was a bit hard to believe, but after the big reveal all of that made sense (the details he knew about Will; his occasionally more educated comments), so kudos.

I will say, the dude looked nothing at all like Jeff Daniels. I think it would have been interesting if they had cast someone who looked more like him, it would have got the gears turning in my head a lot sooner.

reply

If he looked like him then maybe that would have made it too obvious. Maybe that's also why they had him played by an actor younger than Jeff, or perhaps he died around that age. I don't know. Looking back on it now you can tell he was having a conversation with himself, I mean his "father" had an answer for everything, they were like an old married couple...sort of. haha It was great seeing not so perfect Will and his internal conflict. I was hoping to see him lose his composure a little more than that though.

"the day I tried to live, I learned that I was alive"

reply