MovieChat Forums > Unbroken (2014) Discussion > Lets look at the American atrocities on ...

Lets look at the American atrocities on Japan


In 1946, the Manhattan Engineer District published a study that concluded that 66,000 people were killed at Hiroshima out of a population of 255,000.
The Committee for the Compilation of Materials on Damage Caused by the Atomic Bombs in Hiroshima and Nagasaki estimated in 1978 that 346,000-356,000 people were present in Hiroshima at the time of the bombings, with fatalities of "some 200,000".
Casualty estimates for immediate deaths in Hiroshima range from 40,000 to 75,000. Total deaths by the end of 1945 may have reached 80,000.

Japan on the other hand, Pearl Harbor: The assault, which lasted less than two hours, claimed the lives of more than 2,500 people. WTF

reply

Written like someone who has only read the Cliff Notes version of WWII.

Japan was responsible for the slaughter of anywhere between 5 to 10 MILLION Chinese.

Leading up to WWII, in the "Rape of Nanjing" alone (1937), in over six weeks Japan murdered an estimated 40,000 to 300,000 Chinese.

Over 5 MILLION Koreans were enslaved by Japan starting in 1939. The exact number killed is still debated.

Add in all the other Asian-Pacific atrocities driven by the Japanese war culture of that time, Japan was responsible for more deaths than the Nazis.

During war, no nation is exempt from committing atrocities. However, in retrospect and through the clearer eyes of historical review, the United States and Great Britain were responsible for the fewest number of casualties by any estimate.

You have a right to your opinion. Just make it an informed and intelligent one.

reply

syllee,

Written like someone who proudly attended community college and majored in something especially academically "challenging," like urban studies. (The learned Rev. Al Sharpton's degree at CCNY, I believe).

When I graduated from college, I worked for a man, who had served as a sergeant in General Patton's Third Army during WW II. I remember him telling me of how outraged he and his fellow G.I.s were after learning of how the SS had slaughtered American soldiers, who had surrendered to the Germans at Malmedy. (Maybe you learned ALL about that specific war crime after seeing Henry Fonda and James MacArthur in the film, "The Battle of the Bulge"?)

As a result, this man related that the Americans were SO "ticked-off," that whenever they took German prisoners, they would make the German sit on the hood of the jeep they were riding in, and make the German sit there with his hands clasped together behind his head.

Now, the Americans would tell the German that if he put his hands down on the hood of the jeep to steady himself as they drove over the rough terrain, they would automatically assume that he was trying to escape and shoot him in the back of the head, which they actually did to many of their German prisoners, particularly the hated members of the SS.

I could go on about how my own late father also saw many atrocities committed by the Germans while he was a first lieutenant in the infantry, serving with the famed Texas 36th Division in Tunisia (at the Kasserine Pass), Algeria, Italy (at the first Allied landing of Nazi-occupied Europe on the beach at Salerno, and at the long and bloody taking of the Benedictine Abbey at Monte Cassino), France, and Germany (Oberhoffen, where he told me he saw more dead Germans and Americans than he had seen previously in North Africa, Italy and France).

Yet, the incident that he told that he would never forget was when his regiment was sent in to liberate and evacuate the surviving prisoners at Landsberg Prison. Now, Landsberg Prison was also the penal institution where the maniacal Adolf Hitler had been imprisoned years before the war and had penned his "opus," entitled "Mein Kampf."

By the time my father's regiment had reached Landsberg Prison, the Germans had been using the former state prison as a concentration camp, for Jews, intellectuals, gypsies, homosexuals, and other segments of the German population whom the Nazis considered "undesirable."

I will never forget my father relating how unbelievably horrible it was to see the bodies of so many people, whose corpses had been tossed into open freight cars like garbage after having been either being shot or lynched, and just decaying and rotting in the hot sun. "I couldn't eat for a week after witnessing that Hell," my father told me years later.

Unfortunately, several weeks after witnessing that horrific scene at Landsberg Prison, my father was severely wounded by a German artillery shell fragment, which left him 60% disabled, with the loss of one of his lungs, and would ultimately shorten his life greatly. (Oh yeah, my dad was also awarded two Bronze Stars for his bravery in action during the fighting in the E.T.O.)

Gee, I don't know, but in addition to studying about World War II in high school and in undergraduate school, reading so many excellent books on the subject, and having been privileged to discuss the war with World War II veterans like my late father, my four uncles (who served as soldiers and sailors battling the equally evil Japanese in the Pacific), and many older men I know who had served during that all-too-bloody war, I think I have a "slightly" better understanding, appreciation, and knowledge of that conflict than an apparently presumptuous popinjay like you.


Attillio


reply

Your hindsight is a joke. The Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor without declaring war. Did even you know that? That was the worst possible thing the Japanese could have done and that's exactly what happened. After the bombing at Pearl Harbor Naval Marshall General Isoroku Yakamoto wrote in his diary, 'I fear all we have done is to awaken a sleeping giant and fill him with a terrible resolve.' That's exactly what the Japanese did with their sneak attack. It's almost like they deliberately created the sneak attack to ramp up the US war machine.

They tortured women, too. My mother's friend was interred in a Japanese POW camp. She was pregnant. When she went into labor the prison guards tied her legs together. Because of this, her daughter was stillborn. She still grieved 60 years later.

Had the Japanese had surrendered there would have been no atomic bomb. Your comparison of Pearl Harbor to Hiroshima and Nagasaki is insane troll logic. Wars are meant to be won. Not to sound all schoolyard, but they started it.

What about the Kamikaze attacks? You failed to mention them. Japan was desperate and running out of resources, pilots and options. Japan had plans to strap bombs on schoolchildren and meet invading US forces with their suicide children. The US atomic bombs stopped that threat. Do you think GIs should have been blown apart by innocent-looking kiddies? No. Freaking. Way. The war had to end.

Too many of my family died in camps in the Holocaust and in fighting on D-Day for pseudo intellectuals to re-fight the war in retrospect. Some of them were heroes and one was a baseball star.* I'm far from a war hawk but we paid dearly to put down the the dictators. If you think you can do better then you go in harm's way next time. We'll stand back and watch you bleed and die.



http://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.cgi?id=brewer001for

Great white sharks are attracted to death metal music.

reply

lexyladyjax,

In the book "Enola Gay" (which was the name of the Hiroshima-bound B-29 bomber piloted by Col. Paul Tibbetts and also Col. Tibbetts' mother's maiden name), the author points out that Col. Tibbett never had any doubts about flying the Enola Gay over Hiroshima on that bombing mission.

In fact, after visiting Japan after the surrender in 1945, Col. Tibbett was even more convinced that the dropping of the atomic bombs on Hiroahima and Nagasaki were necessary to force the Japanese to quit the war. Col. Tibbett witnessed many of the gun emplacements and booby traps that the Japanese had prepared for when the Allied soldiers hit the beaches of Japan.

My own late uncle, who was a sailor in the US Navy during World War II, related to me how he and thousands of other American sailors, soldiers and marines walked through the devastated streets of Hiroshima only weeks after the city had been leveled. And those men were thankful that President Truman had made the decision to drop the atomic bombs on Japan. In fact, the late Margaret Truman once related, that in the years following the end of World War II, many American veterans would come up to her to thank her late father for deciding to authorize the two atomic bombings, and, thereby, probably saving their lives.

reply

lol @ the thought of "Tit for Tat" warfare! How did you get to be such a simpleton?

reply

It is unfortunate that my father never had the great pleasure (no doubt) of making your acquaintance at Festung Landsberg back in 1945, you diminutive guttersnipe.

reply

Two wrongs don-t make a right, even though war-mongers would like you to believe otherwise.
Dropping a nuclear bomb on anyone is unexcusable. Notice how no one talks about doing that to ISIS and dropping one on Syria| And they are much worse

reply

Sounds like material for a different movie. GRAVE OF THE FIREFLIES was great while only focusing on a single side of the war. Trying to tell all stories in 2 hours ends up telling no stories well.

reply

The U.S. had lost many in the island hopping campaign, with Okinawa being one of the most brutal. To invade Japan proper would have bled our military to death, and would have been viewed as an unforgivable act by the
American people. Truman did the right thing, as horrible as it was. Better them than us.

reply

@fnm_92. IDIOT! Could you imagine explaining to the American people that we had a bomb to end the war and save a million American soldiers ,Marines and sailors that would have been killed in an invasion of Japan? And we didn't use it. geesh gimme a break.

reply