MovieChat Forums > A Dog's Purpose (2017) Discussion > So, Mutilation and Inbreeding is OK Dog ...

So, Mutilation and Inbreeding is OK Dog Lovers?

posted 7 years ago by jtu616
8 replies | jump to latest

Let me get this straight, You take wolves out of their natural habitat, domesticate them to be your personal slaves, castrate them or inbreed them to get the perfect mix (regardless of disease) - but you're mad as hell about a dog being forced into water?

A clinic that sterilizes cats & dogs recently opened not far from where I live in a building that use to be a steak restaurant. Ironic, try explaining that to your kids.

Dog Lover's, you are hypocrites and you're sick, filling your bellies with meat while you cry about the mistreatment of dogs and you also never talk about the thousands of people who are bitten by these poor dogs every year.

[–] Alondro 7 years ago

And I personally don't care either way!

So no hypocrisy here! >:}

[–] debtfull 7 years ago

Spaying and neutering is over rated.

[–] jtu616 7 years ago

Why is that?

Dogs have been elevated to Human status as family members. No sane person would Castrate their kids or have them mate.

[–] TheCountDracula 7 years ago

Dogs have been elevated to Human status as family members.

Which is sad.

"That fückin' Flowers." - Lucas Davenport

[–] IcarusFlies 7 years ago

In order to make dogs behave and elevate to that family status, spaying and neutering is necessary.

It makes the dogs less aggressive because they don't have those hormones running through their body. It's part of domestication. So you still can't compare human children to dogs because children are still given the opportunity to reproduce whereas a dog's natural instinct to reproduce needs to be limited unless you plan on breeding them.

[–] playbillhound 7 years ago

You take wolves out of their natural habitat, domesticate them to be your personal slaves, castrate them or inbreed them to get the perfect mix (regardless of disease) - but you're mad as hell about a dog being forced into water?

Yet many say their other problem with the movie, (abuse allegations aside) is the whole concept of a dog reincarnating to make humans happy - and that a dogs purpose isn't to satisfy humans, while in the same breath citing their reasoning for a dog being forced into water being worse than the things the other all the other animals face at the hands of humans is because "dogs are mans best friend."

[–] tyrexden 7 years ago

is here your argument here, 'this thing isn't bad, because other people do bad stuff too?".

Sorry... not a very compelling argument.

[–] liscarkat (16592) 7 years ago

Yet another idiot who doesn't know what "ironic" means.