MovieChat Forums > Kim Bok-nam salinsageonui jeonmal (2012) Discussion > Liked the film but was really irritated ...

Liked the film but was really irritated by


the brief inclusion of the white half-wit at the beginning of the film.

Why would a young white male be hanging around with a couple of lowlife women beating Korean gangsters? I live in Seoul at the moment and the national media here love nothing more than to have a go at Johnny Foreigner, and what a bad influence he is on Korean society. If you read certain newspapers here you'd believe that all foreigners residing here are gambling,drug using sex offenders.

Nearly all young white men living in South Korea are either U.S army or English teachers. English teachers must go through a rigorous screening in order to get a visa to work here, F.B.I/national criminal checks, apostilled/notarized copies of diplomas, blood tests to detect drug use. My experience with U.S servicemen here is that they don't really mingle with Koreans, and tend to go out in groups for drinks/food. What with their base curfews and whatnot I'm not sure on the likelihood they would forge a friendship with Korean gangsters either. Plus, the man doesn't look like he's U.S army, he looks like a teacher. So who the **** is this character, and where has he come from?

What's so dissappointing is that it's a good film, yet the director felt it necessary for two absolute scumbags to have a Western pal. What went through his mind? Did he read about a couple of teachers getting caught posting cannabis to themselves and decide that after teaching all day they more than likely relax by hanging out in the Korean underworld, perhaps he caught the news report on the illegal foreigner gambling den, whereby teachers would get together for a game of poker and concluded this was a clear sign of the inherent degradation within the English teaching community.

Whatever the directors reasoning it's a pretty poor choice and I have little respect for him despite his making a good film.
As for the twonk that actually played the part I hope you never have the misfortune of meeting me on the streets of Seoul you utter arsewipe.

reply

[deleted]

That's hilarious! Very clever!

reply

No, but I was typing with one hand.

reply

You're right - there are no bad white people.

Back here on planet earth a much more valid complaint would be that they would threaten her at all, since they do it AFTER she has exonerated them in the lineup. There's no reason to antagonize her at that point.


"I'll book you. I'll book you on something. I'll find something in the book to book you on."

reply

well in the beginning of the film they show some white foreigners walking on the streets too. i think the director was just showing seoul as a meltingpot of people, good and bad.

reply

There are bad white people?
Yeah, as I said, Korea has strict laws on allowing foreign nationals to work/reside here. The bad white people, the ones who prefer to hang out with gangsters don't get through immigration.
Back here on planet Earth, any white/black/hispanic/African person who has managed to negotiate the Korean visa process, and presumable learnt enough Korean to communicate fluently, is very unlikely to hang out with a couple of hoodlums.

The thing is, Seoul is not a melting pot. South Korea is one of the most homogenous countries in the world. Compared to other capital cities both in the West and in other Asian countries there are very few foreign people here.

reply

Have you considered the theory that the white kid (who looks actually nothing more than a kid) is a kid of another white person who lives and works in Seoul? It could be the case, because I've read news about Western young people causing troubles in strict countries such as Singapore or Japan, and they happen to be kids who tagged along with their parents to a new country.
I mean seriously, the strict visa process works for the most parts, but cannot be seen as the ultimate solution for restricting bad seeds coming to a certain country, even one as conservative as Korea.

reply

"since they do it AFTER she has exonerated them in the lineup. There's no reason to antagonize her at that point." they didn't know that.

reply

Maybe it's a response to Hollywood's decades of portraying foreigners as evil? I mean seriously, that's always been common. It may not be as prevalent nowadays, but evil foreigners in American films is nothing new. Or the white male saving other cultures. Do you get offended by Hollywood films that contain negative portrayals of foreigners?

Also, the most evil characters in the film are Korean, so...

reply

it's ironic you make all these assumptions, just as silly and hastily as media, when it could be as simple as part of the crew or an intern or something. this movie defies logic in a few ways not just this one lol

Plot hole - Aspect of a film that is misunderstood or missed while using your smart phone.

reply

So you're saying that there is no such person in all of South Korea? Also wanting to do harm to the ACTOR that played a person in a work of FICTION?? Really? You have problems!!!

I don't love her.. She kicked me in the face!!

reply

[deleted]