MovieChat Forums > The Greatest Showman (2017) Discussion > P.T. Barnum wasn't a song and dance man

P.T. Barnum wasn't a song and dance man


I went into this not knowing that it was loosely based on the life of P.T. Barnum. He was the most famous man of his era, thanks in part to his autobiography that he allowed any print house to print, merely to give him more fame. His autobiography was the 2nd most printed book after the Bible.

He was considered a master of marketing and publicity stunts, and inspired Michael Jackson in the 80s to create fantastical tales about his own life (including buying the elephant mans bones, bathing in mineral water and sleeping in an oxygen chamber.)

So I was surprised that 'The Greatest Showman' was about him. They made out that he was 'celebrating humanity' with his freak show. I don't know if that really was the case.

Whatever the case was, I didn't get the feeling that Jackman's character was a genius, a visionary, or master of publicity.

If I were the producers, I would have removed the name Barnum and made it loosely based on his life, but changing details to show that it isn't a biopic (the movie based upon Bill Clintons raise to the presidency, Primary Colors, changed his name to 'Stanton' and changed Chelsea to a boy.)

By changing the names you aren't held to the same scrutiny.

reply

Barnum was considered to be an entertainer who brought forth a lot of oddities in the hopes that it would make him famous. It did. He may not have been the most likable man or the most ingenious but this movie shows that he played to what the public wanted. I think more so this movie was interested in the pageantry and the wow factor of the Barnum personae, and I think it captured both those things well, plus the music was fantastic. It's not perfect, but it's a joy to watch.

I'm trying to go for an entertaining, informative youtube channel so, if you have the time, take a look. Hope you enjoy what you see and if you have any thoughts or criticisms, i'd love to hear them. Thanks in advance. Review right here-https://youtu.be/8_-6y44Ueio

reply