MovieChat Forums > Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny (2023) Discussion > Would it have worked better if Teddy... ...

Would it have worked better if Teddy... (Spoilers)

posted a year ago by christomacin (4567)
5 replies | jump to latest

had been killed instead of kidnapped when the baddies catch up with him in Sicily?

Would it have been a stronger inflection point for Helena to have a change of heart instead of how and why she changes in the film? Would his death would have forced her to face the consequences of her actions in a more dramatic way? Would have been too dark for a family film?

Problem: Who would have flown the second plane in which they return if not Tedy? Or could they have returned another way?

[–] Crapshoot (150) a year ago

Killing off the tagalong child character would’ve probably been seen as too depressing for an Indiana Jones movie, especially when they already established that Mutt died.

[–] christomacin (4567) a year ago

Yeah..OK, how about this: Helena and Indy THINK Teddy is dead temporarily - much like Indy and the audience thought Marion was dead for a while in Raiders? This way he can still fly plane, and not depress the audience, while at the same time giving Helena a stronger character arc.

[–] [deleted] a year ago

When I first heard early info and spoilers about this movie (and I think it's in the trailer, too) I really couldn't believe that the kid could actually fly a plane, I thought it was ridiculous.

But when I saw the film, he's got a pretend cockpit control panel and controls where he can practice flying, so that seemed much more reasonable.

[–] christomacin (4567) a year ago

It was a paper thin explanation but at least it was there.... and Short Round learned to drive a car in I would assume much the same way.

[–] [deleted] a year ago

To drive a car is much easier than flying a plane, although Short Round needed physical assistance via wooden blocks tied to his feet to reach the pedals as he was so small, which is cute.