MovieChat Forums > Never Let Me Go (2010) Discussion > Your most memorable scene from the movie...

Your most memorable scene from the movie?


I absolutely loved this movie regardless of all the haters out there pointing out all the trivial flaws. The story is beyond organ donations and why they didn't run away, it is about life and relationships.

I think for me the best part of the movie was the last scene where Cathy H says " After all we are not different from the 'normal' people . Everyone has to go through completion at some point in their life and no one ever feels they have lived enough!"


Trying is the first step towards failure.

reply

hardbore,

I loved this movie too. My favorite part was Tommy's look of not only disbelief
but horror when they were told they could not have their 2 year delay. How much
time he must have spent on the drawings. How much hope they both had.

Marge









reply

I agree Marge.. That also was one of the scenes etched in my mind. And the way he just walks out after hearing it , gave me the chills..
All in all, an amazing watch :)

Trying is the first step towards failure.

reply

I love this movie too...and I agree with you one hundred percent. It's not about trying to run away so they could have more time, it's about what they did with the time they had.
I think if I had to pick a scene it's when Kathy stops reading to Tommy and gets in his bed with him...not because they are going to have sex but because that's when they begin their time together. Even if it was only weeks or months, they did get time together.

"No Good Deed Goes Unpunished"

reply


I agree with you entirey, lojo414. I also liked the way Tommy nervously touches his face when Kathy is about to get in the bed, it was lovely.

But the two scenes that stayed the most with me are related to Tommy and Ruth and their surgeries. When Ruth dies, they just leave her there. And her face wasn't even covered when they were operating on her. I think this emphasyses the fact that the PEOPLE (scientists) around thought the clones subhuman or something of the sort. I noticed something similar when Tommy is about to have his last surgery: as soon as the anesthesia has kicked in, the doctors grab his face harshly and manipulate his body as if it were a mere object. And they don't care about Kathy watching them.





Show me a hero and I will write you a tragedy
KEIRAHOLIC NÂș4

reply

I think Tommy's reaction is why I like that scene so much.

The two scenes you mentioned get me too. The very first time I saw this movie it was on HBO and I turned on the TV just as Ruth had flatlined and I very much had a, "What the????" moment so I watched it later from beginning to end and I also noticed how Tommy was struggling to keep his eyes open and on Kathy for as long as possible and then they just pounce on him while she is obviously still standing there.

I've read the book too and I think I like the characters in the movie better than the same ones in the book. They seem very starched in the book, but it was good to get some insight into some of the scenes in the film.



"No Good Deed Goes Unpunished"

reply

Those two scenes hit me hardest as well. How little any of the medical team cared about them. They were quietly disturbing and stuck with me. It almost physically hurts the way they pounce on Tommy as soon as his eyes close and start putting leads and probes on him him while tossing his head around so roughly.

reply

I'll never forget how disturbed I was by the way the medical team handled and processed Tommy as if he was just another piece of meat instead of a living, breathing, loving human being. Cold, methodical, without an ounce of tenderness, respect, compassion, or hesitation. Like how a chef might cut up a whole chicken in his kitchen.

reply

I have two: when Kathy meets Ruth again at the hospital and they walk along the corridor with Ruth using a zimmer frame for aid and she turns to Kathy and says something like 'I must seem quite broken to you'. What a remarkable moment in terms of acting, dialogue and impact. My second favourite is when Tommy tells Kathy he knew why she was looking at the porno magazine and then tells her in a voice that breaks slightly that her sexual feelings had been normal. This moment hurt so much as it showed the empathy between Kathy and Tommy that is what should have united them as a couple but didn't until the end.

Why problem make? When you no problem have, you don't want to make ...

reply

My favorite scene would be when Kathy asked Tommy if he and Ruth will apply for a deferral and Tommy said it is not possible because Kathy had so much things in the gallery and somehow he expressed his love for her...

My Sci-Fi! Run Lola Run, Donnie Darko, Eternal Sunshine, Never Let Me Go, Melancholia

reply

I took that to mean that it wasn't Ruth he was in love with, but had always been Kathy.

reply

I totally agree!

reply

The moments I remember the best are often the ones that left the biggest impact, so here goes:

When they are in the cafe and all three order the same as the first guy (don't remember his name) just like Tommy did when they were rehearsing as children.

Same scene, but later, when referrals are brought up for the first time and everyone acts so strange - it really made me see that these people don't have a well developed social intelligence. And then the girl (don't remember her name) says something like "why do you keep it to yourself? Why can't the rest of us get referrals too?" - it just seemed like there was a double-meaning there.

When Tommy realizes referrals isn't real. Just the look on his face.

When Ruth dies and then later when Tommy dies. The way the doctors handled them, the look in Ruth's eyes... just everything.

reply

I didn't like that. To say that donors are essentially the same as non-donors because "we all gotta go sometime," and "everyone feels like they haven't had enough time," negates everything that went before it in the film - the horror of a donor's life, the evil of raising human beings as organ farms, the suffering they went through. And most of all, the early death, which is not just a possibility, as it is with non-donors, but is a CERTAINTY. They are not the same. This scene seemed to imply that none of all that donor stuff really mattered - what counts is making the best of whatever time you have. And that really disappointed me. If that's the moral of the story, doesn't it trivialize all the issues raised earlier in the film?

reply

[deleted]

the early death, which is not just a possibility, as it is with non-donors, but is a CERTAINTY. They are not the same. This scene seemed to imply that none of all that donor stuff really mattered - what counts is making the best of whatever time you have.

There are two interlocking themes there.
1. the horror of a society which builds the clone factory, suggesting that it is the clones who have the humanity while the rest of society has lost part of its humanity, and

2. what counts really is what you do with the rest of your life, whatever took you to where you are now. I am reminded of a recent execution of two Australians in Indonesia for organising a drug mule operation smuggling heroin from Bali to Australia. They spent 10 years on death row teaching and mentoring inmates and where they both converted to Christianity.
All we can ever do with our lives is what we have left of it, however short or long time we have left.

In his cloak of words strode the ringmaster

reply

When Ruth dies but also when the Madame says "i wish i could help you", touches her face before they part ways, and they have the same hair, color and length...

reply

I absolutely loved the scene where the kids are all gathered together at Hailsham, in that great big hall, and Kathy looks over to Tommy and sees Ruth taking his hand. In the context of the plot leading up to that point, it was just brilliant. While I felt sorry for Kathy I found the trickery, her pain and shock oddly entertaining. Had me smiling for minutes.

reply

Where the doctors took out Kathy's liver or whatnot and left the carcass on the table. Delicious viciousness, brutality at its best.

reply