MovieChat Forums > The Butler (2013) Discussion > Who else found the casting too distracti...

Who else found the casting too distracting ?


I mean I spent half he time going: oh! it's so and so! It took away from the story and the authentic feel they were going for. I mean seriously:
-Mariah Carey as a plantation worker, yeah really? Mariah Carey?
-Leny Kravitz as a butler. I was like: "didn't know he was trying to be an actor now"
-And why choose famous actors for the presidents? Every, single one of them. I had to laugh when I recognized Alan Rickman as Reagan.

I feel that the casting was some kind of school boy's fantasy. The movie stopped being about the story or the characters and became instead all about the celebrity who's who. I was half expecting Kim Kardashian to be one of the Black Panthers or something (yeah I'm exaggerating slightly, but barely really!) This was a pity: I think better casting would have elevated this piece.

reply

I was also surprised Mariah Carey was in this movie considering she has no lines and her screen time is a whopping 1.2 minutes. However, I found most of the other actors refreshing.

Not gonna lie, I giggled a little when I realized Robin Williams was playing Eisenhower.

reply

Re: Robin Williams as Eisenhower. I chuckled too. Not being negative just ....didn't know if he fit that role too well LOL

reply

I found much of the casting to be distracting also. It seems like it would have been better to hire some solid but lesser known actors to play the historical characters. (When I saw Jane Fonda as Nancy Reagan I just about lost it.) Star power in those roles did not lend itself to making this movie any better in any way. Distracting? Yes! I did like Vanessa Redgrave, but she didn't play a well known historical character...though she probably could have pulled it off better than anyone else if she was given such a role.

reply

[deleted]

I can appreciate the casting being distraction, I too, was affected to a degree.

That said, perhaps the casting of these people in these roles was an effort to reach out to people who could resonate with the main topic of the civil rights issues under evaluation. I don't follow these actors that much but I am thinking at some degree their past comments and activities have become known that they would like to support the project out of either a direct or indirect connection with the subject of civil rights globally, nationally, and personally as applied to the main character and his family.

reply

Really bizarre decisions, they were just missing Sam L Jackson and Laurence Fishburne.

reply

I found it distracting that the casting was an in-your-face parade of radical leftie actors. (Of course, few in Hollywood aren't) -- I think the only ones missed were Martin Sheen and Edward Asner. (or is he finally dead yet?)

reply

I watched it last night, totally forgot Mariah Carey was in it and didn't recognize her and just said out loud, "THAT WAS MARIAH CAREY?!" They really made LBJ look like a total hick and a joke--I was trying to figure out who the actor was and quickly looked it up on my phone as I was watching and didn't recognize Liev Schreiber! John Cusack as Nixon! I didn't know who he was supposed to be at first--like the sweating touch he added! I thought he was good without exaggerating Nixon's mannerisms. Jane Fonda--I liked the way she did this thing with her head like Nancy Reagan, but the sexy walk didn't seem to fit! I found it entertaining seeing these actors in such roles but I know what you mean. I think I was expecting more from this because of the raves a friend had about it. Oh, in the beginning when the boy broke into the store to eat the cake, the old man who caught him seemed so familiar. I kept trying to figure out who he was--for those who remember The Mod Squad--he was Linc! I admit a lot of the dialogue was lost to me.

reply

Of course it was distracting, and pathetic too. Terrible casting with the presidents.

reply

Agree, the casting is very weird to me in the sense that the scenes with the presidents aren't well done and the actors don't act well. Two exceptions: I like Rickman and Fonda here.
To me Opra is the worst, bad acting.

reply

Oprah, worst acting? Really? Preposterous. Forrest Whittaker is critically acclaimed as is Oprah, Cuba Gooding Jr and Terrence Howard. You're an idiot. Please delete your IMDB account and stop wasting your time with ridiculous commentary based on no knowledge of film actors outside the White genre.

reply

Casting Uncle Ruckus from The Boondocks as Old Forrest Whittaker made me laugh a little, especially his over-the-top old man-nerisms.

reply