MovieChat Forums > Whip It (2009) Discussion > How come no in this movie has a Texan ac...

How come no in this movie has a Texan accent?


Not even one? Or just have it in a different setting?

reply

Being a Texan, I can truthfully say that not EVERY Texan has an accent. Especially not around the Austin area! But then again, maybe it's because I've lived here all my life that I don't hear an accent. LOL!

*I feel like I'm in Derek Zoolander's Center For Kids Who Can't Read (or spell) That Good*

reply

and why do they all sound like they have a lisp?

reply

I am a native Austinite, born and raised here in Austin, Texas my whole life - Austin is where the movie takes place (or is supposed to, anyway - some of it was filmed here some of it in Michigan.). This may sound realllly weird to you but most people in Austin and surrounding areas including small nearby towns like the one Bliss is from DONT have Texas accents, not even a little bit. SOME people do, and thats shown in the film, several of the roller derby girls have twangs, slight Texas accents and as a Texan I can tell you honestly they do a good job. I've heard my share of twangs to heavy Texas accents too. Every part of Texas is different and Austin and the towns nearby are a mix of a lot of different people from all over including Texans mainly from allll over the state who come or came at some point or other because well like Bliss they want a new good life where they feel like they fit in and belong and can be themselves, have a new life, fulfill their dreams, whatever. Make sense now? Much love and hope you are well! Oh especially in the alternative cultures and subcultures in and near Austin people don't usually have accents. And roller derby is an alternative culture/subculture obviously and Bliss and her friends in her hometown and in Austin both are pretty alternative - by alternative in these usages i just mean not super common, not the average person in the places where they live and such (though i must say roller derby is popular in austin texas and overall austin is an alternative city). hope this answers your question well. much love and peace.

reply

Born an raised in the DFW area and though its not quite Austin it is true many Texans don't have accents...or rather we don't have the cartoon southern accents you here in mainstream country music or westerns. It is refreshing to see a film depict Texans a bit closer to reality.

http:/citizenchris099.blogspot.com/

reply

some have the accents and some do not. I was raised in texas and spent most of my life there...and from an early age I tried to NOT have an accent...with some success (it comes out after about 9 beers). I think Daniel Stern nailed the accent though...sounds like all of my friends' dads...haha

reply

People in what is called the Texas Triangle, meaning the urban region that includes Denton, Dallas, Ft. Worth, San Antonio, Houston, Galveston, and Austin, don't sound like J. R. Ewing. Movies and TV shows usually get that so wrong, and the locals make fun of it.

I've been told when I travel that I lack a Texas accent. I always reply that I actually do have one. Mine's real. :)

Speaking of local touches, loved that people in the movie were drinking Shiner Bock. That's the Texas beer we drink in the Triangle, not Lone Star. It's one of the best beers America produces, an American beer that Europeans wouldn't make fun of like most of our wimpy attempts at beer. :)

reply

Austin people seem to turn it on and off whenever they want. I think we sound like Laura Bush --Owen Wilson, Sissy Spacek, Thomas Haden Church, Jennifer Garner all from Texas but they can sound very Texan or not.

There are so many people here from California, Minnesota, Michigan, New York, Louisiana, and Texas and just about any state or country you can think of!!

I would call it a relaxed version of normal English.
A little Southern-- a little Okie-- & dropping our "ings" for sure.


reply

Funny. Not everyone here in Texas speaks like a hick. Nor do we all have a southern drawl. And no, we don't all live on a ranch and have cows. (I spoke to someone from Portugal and he thought we still used horses and carriages in Texas!)

I am in East Texas and I have a regular Texas accent. It's cute and charming but not everyone has one. And no, I am not offended that it is supposed to be based in Texas and no one had an accent. :) It's a movie!




Greatest Silent Hill fan...EVER.

reply

Here is an interesting dialect/accent map of the usa - and Texas

http://aschmann.net/AmEng/#LargeMap5Right

reply

Texas is a state of transplants and has a history of that. So Texans, like my 4th generation self, don't even have a Texas accent!

And different regions of the state have different accents.

reply

Does it really matter?

reply

In my opinion, there is really no such thing as a Texas accent. The state is huge and quite diverse so you can't really pin down a speech pattern that sounds Texan. Grab someone from Beaumont, San Antonio, Dallas, and Lubbock and it's unlikely they'll have the same accent, if they have any discernible one at all. It's something that movies often get wrong; this movie didn't.

reply

I think people in Texas big cities have all but lost any semblence of an accent - but small towns are a little different. West Texas has a different accent than East Texas, which is closer to deep south than in the west. Southeast Texas has a bayou influence, the hill country has a strong German influence, the rio grande valley has an obvious hispanic influence and people in the panhandle and the west have their own too.

Texas is too diverse to nail an accent very well, but it seems like everyone I know in Texas can do one if they want to. Uncanny!

I don't think movies ever get Texas accents down unless it's by an authentic Texan. And yet I think Heath Ledger in Brokeback Mountain sounded very country Texan.

reply