MovieChat Forums > Orphan (2009) Discussion > Esther locking the bathroom door

Esther locking the bathroom door


I find it funny how the movie made that moment seem strange and the camera zoomed in like it was a big deal. Doesn't everyone lock the door when they bath or shower? I just found Kate to be weird there, Esther's obviously a very mature child shes not a bumbling 5 year old who will drown. Esther was right, John or Daniel could have walked in at anytime.

"No we don't lock doors in this house" Really? Kind of a stupid rule when you have 2 guys and 3 girls living under the same roof, So Esther can be in there changing and she just has to hope no one comes in?

Thats what i love about these high school girls, i get older they stay the same age.

reply

I thought her locking the door intentionally was to have time to get rid of her wristband and necklace. It's obvious people don't see why would she do that.

reply

When I was growing up, we didn't lock the bathroom door in case of an accident, like falling in the tub. I know it's unlikely but it's just one of those things that parents often do. We also didn't look our bedroom doors when we went to sleep in case of fire or another urgent need to vacate the house. But, I also agree with your point that a self-possessed, mature girl like Esther could have been trusted to leave door locked, or to not have her mother gaurding outside. .

Earth. Welcome.

reply

That part of the movie was really odd. The mom's paranoia was understandable, but you have a 9 year-old girl who was recently introduced to the family and her new father and brother are still strangers to her you should respect her need for some privacy. A girl that age is on the verge of puberty after all.

It was also odd that the dad didn't pick up on Esther's attempts to appear younger than her alleged age. She did not act like a 9 year-old. The mom realized the way she dressed was weird, but the dad didn't give it a second thought. He also kept referring to himself and his wife as "mommy" and "daddy" and encouraging her to as well. This would be odd for any 9 year-old and especially a recent adoptee.

~The internet? Is that thing still around?~

reply

Idk, many children still say mommy and daddy at that age. Kate's just protective, especially since Max's accident.

reply

One of the reasons I didn't like the mother.

reply

At that point, she WAS starting to get suspicious and notice odd things about her. Like lying about her piano playing skills and her antic looking frilly dress she wore to school.

reply