MovieChat Forums > Slumdog Millionaire (2008) Discussion > Does it make sense ?

Does it make sense ?

posted 8 years ago by Moviebuff0001
10 replies | jump to latest

All the questions Prem was asking in the program looked very artificial ! I mean whatever Jamal has experienced in his life was asked as questions (except one- that too he guessed right! ) and it didn't look real. I mean how many times all the questions asked in a such a program involving so much money are all the ones you experienced in your life ?! Looks like the questions were just inserted into the script in a hurry to move the story forward and sounded illogical.Just imo. Any thoughts ?

[–] Moviebuff0001 8 years ago

Bump

[–] imadbasayev 8 years ago

That was the whole point of the movie you dump truck. That's why he made it as far as he did and that's why he was interrogated. Also, he didn't know all the answers, he had to guess the last two.

[–] Moviebuff0001 8 years ago

Im talking whether the script sounds logical you clever boy ! Investigation just sounds like cover for that illogical questions. Just imo (im not saying im right and not here to start a warfare). Just would like to know others opinion too

[–] imadbasayev 8 years ago

You're not the brightest star in the sky, are you..

[–] Moviebuff0001 8 years ago

Yawn

[–] charleyhydel 8 years ago

It's the point of the movie.

[–] evil_nemesis 8 years ago

Don't you guys think the last question was way to easy?

= The Nemesis =

[–] MovieManCin2 (26342) 7 years ago

Yes the last question was a piece of cake.

😎

[–] Helenlaurence 7 years ago

It's a film- it has a fantastical element to it.
Of course it's highly unlikely if not impossible, in real life.
But it gave the film a nice symmetry and helped tell his story.

[–] selectrick 7 years ago

You do realize that that was the whole gist of the movie don't you? The strange coincidence of all those questions relating to past life experiences. Anyway, haven't you ever had one of those days at a poker game where you just can't lose? where it seems that the stars have aligned in your favor for just that short period of time? It's truly a wonderful feeling !