MovieChat Forums > The Hurt Locker (2009) Discussion > As pulsating/intense as Zero Dark Thirty...

As pulsating/intense as Zero Dark Thirty + American Sniper?


Still yet to watch it, now that is on Netflix will definitely check it out, but am curious does it have the same/similar tone to Zero Dark Thirty & American Sniper as in the tension is developed slowly?

Thanks

reply

Not even close to American Sniper IMPO. To me, this was an okay movie. Watching American Sniper I was on edge, heart beating fast and ended up with a tension headache afterward from on stress. LOL

reply

I thought Lone Survivor was more intense than American Sniper

reply

You are right - Lone Survivor IS much more intense than American Sniper. In reality, I didn't find much intensity in Sniper at all.

reply

I have seen all three. Hurt Locker reigns. More simplistic yet very real. Three soldiers trying to repeatedly accomplish a different mission and stay alive. Don't miss it.

He killed sixteen Czechoslovakians. Guy was an interior decorator.

reply

Hurt Locker is the best, but Zero Dark Thirty is a very close second. American Sniper was okay, but a bit over-melodramatic for my tastes (regardless of how much I love the story.)

Jeremy Renner in Hurt Locker is a great performance, he's the intangible that puts it on top imo.

"I do not like mixing up moralities and mathematics."
Churchill

reply

Locker was good but not as intense as Zero Dark Thirty. I still haven't seen Anerican Sniper.

reply

Of the three Zero Dark Thirty is my favorite. It just has a tighter story, imo. I really liked American Sniper too and also this movie. They're all very good movies.

reply

Not to attack anyone for liking these movies but it is just a shame these 3 are popular as they are 3 of the most unpleasant. Zero dark thirty was almost entirely fictional propaganda spoon fed by the CIA, it tries to insinuate torture had something to do with the kill mission on OBL despite being caught out multiple times on the issue. American sniper glorifies and humanises a monster who certainly killed unarmed civilians he held in contempt in order to boost his kill count for bragging rights, lied about fellow soldiers when they were no longer around to give their side and made up dumb stories about veterans with different politics to improve book sales, despite it ruining their relationship with fellow SEALs. The man, in his own words, had none of the humanity of the movie character. Out of all the heroes, why they were ignored to make a propaganda movie about a scumbag is hard to understand, except for Eastwoods hard right swing lately in his personal politics, they even threw in the shot of 9/11 to try make out that Saudi terrorists and the invasion of Iraq had any link.

Then you have this mess of a movie that falls apart about the time of the Merc's showing up and drifts into lala land, even civilians I know have pointed out how ridiculous half the stuff is. Your rifle is jammed so you sit out exposed in the open to clean it? The sniper who just killed a bunch of you then goes away for a tea break until you finish cleaning your gun? Just to show up again in time to get shot? The bomb techs take up the rifle rather than the ex special forces guys with more experience and training? They consider fragging their team mate then for no apparent reason are teary eyed best buddies at the end? The bomber sits and watches you disarm a bomb, THEN walks towards the trigger after it is too late? The guy not only puts himself in danger but his team by dropping smoke between him and them leaving himself exposed and them blind? He decides to go attack the parents of the kid he thinks is killed despite the fact he would have been their sole provider and they are the least likely suspects? They leave it to the bomb techs to go clear a building after sitting outside for how long? The shrink decides to go wander off and get killed just after soldiers stand around chatting in the middle of a hostile area, acting like they are on R&R in the middle of combat?

This movie was a hot mess, it doesn't show reality of combat at all and had no military advisors. Why make a movie about a group of people without researching those same people for more than 5 minutes.

reply

WAY more intense. There are less action scenes but they are filled with like 50 times more tension

reply

I have seen all three films and in the order/years they were released - The Hurt Locker, Zero Dark Thirty and American Sniper.

The Hurt Locker RULES.

I sensed real tension and trepidation watching this film which I found gut wrenching in the "heaviest" scenarios the IED squad was faced with. Kathryn Bigelow directed The Hurt Locker for which she won an Oscar. (Btw, her ex-husband, James Cameron, lost to her in that category with Avatar.) Bigelow definitely earned the award because of her attention to detail, her creativity and determination to complete the film.

All of the actors are good but Jeremy Renner was outstanding in this film. The supporting cast was made up of many Iraqi actors who had become refugees due to the war. And Ralph Fiennes takes a very small part, with little screen time and produces a jewel of a performance.

Great movie.

reply

somewhat of an old thread, but yes, I generally agree with the other comments that if "Zero Dark Thirty" and "American Sniper" are your kind of flavor, then "The Hurt Locker" would be a good bet. I think I may have found "The Hurt Locker" more intense than the other two; I've been able to watch "Zero Dark Thirty" a couple of times, but I haven't been able to finish "The Hurt Locker" the second time around. Somewhat mindless action where there are a bunch of blows to nearly superhuman characters or a bunch of anonymous, average-joe antagonists who die quickly like the Marvel films or Star Wars, I can deal with fairly easily, but the "The Hurt Locker" takes a bit of getting used to.

reply

I found The Hurt Locker very intense upon first viewing. It is a difficult film to watch again knowing the insanity that's coming up. (Another film that was nearly impossible to watch again was Atonement but for different reasons.)
Zero Dark Thirty was a step down but makes me upset when you find out these analysts had been on the right track about the terrorists but largely ignored by the Administration at that time.
American Sniper was a somewhat weak drink of water compared to the other two films. Ironically, last week reports came out about Chris Kyle embellishing his medal count to the point that a former Commander warned him about it but the book was already being published.
The idea that to take a Vet with PTSD, who you don't know well at all, out to a firing range for therapy always seemed strange to me. I'm Vietnam Era Veteran but I've never wanted to own a gun. Not to disrespect Kyle's memory but guns aren't always the answer to every problem. If the movie is accurate, Kyle, as well as many wartime Vets, are not comfortable communicating what goes on in their heads after they have re-entered civilian life.

reply

Not to disrespect Kyle's memory but guns aren't always the answer to every problem.


And no disrespect to you, but Kyle had many problems in the film that he was unable to solve with guns. Nor did he make an effort to answer those problems with guns.

I see these kinds of comments every single time someone mentions American Sniper and it makes me wonder how many of those people actually even watched the movie.

American Sniper is not one of my favorites either, but it's important to note that it is clearly not the same type of film as Zero Dark Thirty or The Hurt Locker. In reality, it's more of a character study in the style of Jarhead or The Deer Hunter. If we're going to compare movies, let's at least compare apples to apples. Instead of comparing two Kathryn Bigelow movies to a Clint Eastwood movie.

reply

Hurt Locker isn't a character study? Are you sure?

reply

I'm not sure what others have been smoking on this thread but this is even more intense and suspenseful than those other two you mentioned. And a better all-round movie imo.

reply

I haven't watched ZDT seriously so I couldn't say about it (only skimmed many scenes, I avoided the torture scenes), but A.S and THL are as same intense to me.

reply