MovieChat Forums > Tropa de Elite (2007) Discussion > Never again I will trust critics.

Never again I will trust critics.


After seeing this movie for the first time, I was insanly suprised by the critics rating:
33 on metacritic?
What the Actual **********!

This is one of the most realistic/violent/action movies i've ever seen.
Might even watch it twice cuz it's kinda funny too.

WOW. The critics are just a piece of ****** mother******!

reply

I was very surprised when I read some of the critics and ratings on Rotten Tomatoes.
This movie is great.

reply

This movie is fantastic, and this is coming from an action movie fan.

reply

It didn't show a simplified black & white version of reality, so some of the critics went as far as calling it fascistic.
My guess is that they identified too much with the liberal smartass pot smoking students and were upset that they weren't potrayed as heroes of the story :^)

reply

They did the same with Dirty Harry:

https://www.rogerebert.com/letters/dirty-harry-is-not-fascist

In retrospect, the criminal justice system of that era was definitely too lenient.

Critics need to understand that it's not their job to discourage people from watching "bad" movies. I've never avoided a movie because of negative reviews. But thanks to positive reviews, I've seen plenty that I otherwise might have skipped.

reply