MovieChat Forums > Palo Alto, CA (2007) Discussion > Palo Alto is NOT a 'small town'. . . .

Palo Alto is NOT a 'small town'. . . .


by any stretch of the imagination. It is a large suburb in the middle of an enormous urban area.

reply

Yeah, not very small. But it's very nice. Very. Such as downtown, University Avenue, etc.

reply

This is funny ... first off Stanford University is not in Palo Alto... Stanford University is in Stanford, CA and is bordered by Palo Alto and Menlo Park . Either way.. who cares. If you enjoy the movie than I say give it some artistic license plus or minus the size of the city.

reply

Palo Alto is veryyyyy small in comparison to other places in the bay. Driving by Palo alto on 101 takes less then a min... unless you're in 5 o clock traffic. ;)

reply

If you judge small towns by ease of parking then PA is definitely not small :) Awful, AWFUL parking. And just to qualify my remarks - I work here.

reply

I don't know much about PA or this area in the film, but I thought I would comment about "small towns."

I'm from Michigan, and lived in a city of about 18,000 people, and then it's also a college town so it boosted the population up to like 35,000+ during the school year. I considered it a relatively smaller city, but there are other cities around the area with 50,000+, and those I considered medium sized cities.

Anything with 100,000+ in population is large for Michigan, other than the Detroit Metro area, but each of those areas has a lot of people, and then of course Detroit itself has a ton.

I would say anything less than 5,000 people is a "small town," and then up to 20,000 is bordering on a larger town or small city.

Anything with 50,000+ people I consider a decent sized city, and obviously 100,000+ is large.

Michigan has a lot of spread out cities with about 40,000-75,000 people, and those are considered the avearge-medium sized cities. So I don't know how people would call those "small towns" in another state. They're neither small in regard to population or land mass.

reply

The whole argument in this thread is ridiculous!

Despite never having been to Palo Alto I do know that 60,000 people live there. Sixty thousand. I grew up in an actual small town...4,000 people in the Berkshire foothills in Connecticut. Two church steeples, a grocery store, a gas station, two banks and some restaurants. Walking around town I would say hello to half the people I met and recognize almost all of them. I spent every day in the summer at the beach in town with friends from school—the only school in town, a K-8 elementary school with 400 kids. I rode my bike or walked to my friends houses and knew everybody my age in town because we all went to the same school. No interstate highways, no shopping malls, no major universities, no crime, nowhere nearby with crime. I went to boarding school but the town wasn't large enough to have its own high school, the school instead being a regional school in a neighboring town.

We were a short drive to New York so it didn't feel isolated, but that was a small town, nowhere with 60,000 people can ever really be a small town.

this behavior is gonna get me nowhere but straight to hell

reply

For an 18 year old Palo Alto could definitely have the feel of a small town because what is there to do there? Go check out Standford campus or Hoover Tower? Oh, I know, being 18 and checking out the garage where HP began sounds fun. Do you want to get wild and go to Moffett Field and then Frys to look at the porn DVDs? Is there even a theater? Or do you have to go to Mountain View? Oh, I know, you could go to the Tesla dealership! Or the Specialty Automotive or whatever and look at Cobras. See, for an 18 year old there is not much to do, so for them it is definitely a small town considering they can go to San Jose in 20 minutes or San Francisco in ~40.

Would you rather live in Palo Alto or Los Altos Hills? Or how about Belmont or Woodside?

reply