I figured that Stevie's consciousness/essence floated off somewhere or changed state when Alex froze her body, and that she was (is) far from dead.
So you are saying that Casper the Friendly Ghost never died, just because he became a ghost and had an afterlife?
So you are saying that Hamlet's father the king was never murdered,merely because his spirit had an afterlife? If So, why did his spirit tell Hamlet he had been murdered and urge Hamlet to avenge that murder? If having an afterlife negates dying (or being killed) and makes it as if the person had never died, why did the ghost of Hamlet's father, aware that he was in an afterlife, insist that he had died and had been murdered?
Are you saying that Darth Vader did not kill Obi-wan Kenobi, merely because Kenobi had an afterlife as a force ghost?
SPOILER ALERT!
Are you claiming that Grima Wormtongue did not murder Saruman in the novel
Return of the King, merely because Saruman's spirit survived the death of his body? Do you suppose that Smeagol did not murder Deagol, merely because hobbits probably have some type of afterlife similar to that of men?
And examples from the
Silmarillion:
Are you saying the Eol the dark elf did not murder his wife by not telling anyone that he had wounded her with a poisoned weapon, merely because the spirits of all slain elves go to the Halls of Mandos and are eventually given new bodies? Do you suppose that Eol was not executed by being thrown off the walls of Gondolin, merely because the spirits of all slain elves go to the Halls of Mandos and are eventually given new bodies?
reply
share