MovieChat Forums > Not Easily Broken (2009) Discussion > I don't get it! Why do all 'black' movie...

I don't get it! Why do all 'black' movies suck?


can u name a good one

reply

Not all black movies

The Brothers
Breaking all the rules
The best man
2 can play that game
Why did I get married?
Kingdom come was a cute one for me too.
there are a lot more of them, but we do make movies with some decent storylines that are not ghettofabulous

New line for 2009? Get over it!

reply

I'm pretty sure the OP was just trying to get some attention, but I'm pretty surprised no one so far has mentioned "Boy'z in the hood" within their suggestions. For me it is one of the most solid "black movies" (whatever) out there.

reply

[deleted]

As a white guy that couldn't stand this movie, I think I understand where the OP is coming from. For me, when I think "Oh, it's a 'black' movie," I'm pretty much thinking of crap like this one. The church, the hood, a "cheating" husband, and some random white guy that is said to have grown up with the main characters but clearly didn't. And for some reason, this particular type of movie I tend to label as "black" remind you about every ten minutes that you're watching black people on-screen.

I won't act like I've seen most of the movies mentioned above, but some I have seen, like Set It Off and Menace II Society (I know, I know, of course I've seen those), don't make me think "black movie." Set It Off is just a good bank robber movie, where the main characters just happen to be black.

The only reason all the bad movies with primarily white actors aren't called "white" movies is because there are just too many of them.

reply

As a white guy that couldn't stand this movie, I think I understand where the OP is coming from. For me, when I think "Oh, it's a 'black' movie," I'm pretty much thinking of crap like this one. The church, the hood, a "cheating" husband, and some random white guy that is said to have grown up with the main characters but clearly didn't. And for some reason, this particular type of movie I tend to label as "black" remind you about every ten minutes that you're watching black people on-screen.


I have to admit this guy does have a point, but like I said before, the people with money think 1) black people ONLY want to see these kinds of movies and 2) they think only these kinds of movies have any chance of making money. It sucks, but it's true. Seven Pounds was decent, but I'd much rather see a Reservoir Dogs or Pulp Fiction-ish intricate indie flick with a mostly black cast that didn't involve rap, the hood, the ghetto, gangs, prison, or drugs. I can only hope.

Go to Virtual Hollywood! http://www.virtual-hollywood.com/drupal/

reply

good black movies? (from Rotten Tomatoes...a good movie is anything over 60%)

Soul Food (80%)
Love and Basketball (82%)
Menance II Society (86%)
Boyz N Da Hood (98%)
Lean on Me (64%)
Rosewood (90%)
Do the Right Thing (100%)
Brown Sugar (65%)
Cooley High (78%)
The Wood (61%)
Friday (80%)

the problem is not that all black movies suck....black movies are right in line with mainstream movies. A mix of great, terrible, and mediocore films. Its just since there are so few black directors that get funding for major films, the bad films standout. Its not helping that the films selling, are the ones black church going women (the demographic for tyler perry fims) flock to and drag their man and or girlfriends. Those films are redundant in theme and cinematography, but def appealing to the large demographic its intended for. They keep selling, so they will keep getting made. Spike Lee has struggled for years to get funding for his films, he dropped the ball with his last film, which will make it even more difficult in the future for him to get funding. Its a tough climate right now...

reply

@@ It never fails. On EVERY black movie and I do mean every black movie there will be at least one white (or other, sometimes even black) person to say "all black films suck"! First of all, it's not true and secondly who are you trying to convince us or yourself? If it sucks so much why are you over HERE on a "black film" thread talking about it? I've seen plenty of crappy white films and I do mean plenty but you don't see me on those threads going all "white films" suck. Christ, get a life.

reply

The Color Purple

Soul Food

reply

There are many but just two off the top of my head:

Soul Food

Color Purple

reply

...With all the epic movies, scary movies, date movie semi pro crap like that that usually has an all white cast don't start on movies with Black actors there are waaaay more stupid movies out there with White people in them I'm not gonna whine over a site about it because I don't care.

Lonely chicago pie

reply