MovieChat Forums > Der Baader Meinhof Komplex (2008) Discussion > I, as communist have no sympathies for t...

I, as communist have no sympathies for the RAF!


Because they were anti-semites!

1.The german left, the anti-imperialists supported the islamic revolution in Iran. And look at Iran nowadays, one of the worst countries on earth, and a threat to Israel! The german left should be ashamed! They deserved to get beaten up by the Shahs henchman!

2.The got trained by the Fedajin. Anti semitic palestinians who fought against Israel. If you do not support Israel, you can't call yourself a communist.

3.The anti-americanism of the RAF was disgusting! No wonder Horst Mahler, Bernd Rabehl and other idiots became Neo-Nazis later, or worked for the german goverment!

4. *beep* the german left!

GERMANY MUST DIE! COMMUNISM NOW!

reply

troll I know, anyway

>>> The german left, the anti-imperialists supported the islamic revolution in Iran

whats your evidence for this ?

>>> The got trained by the Fedajin. Anti semitic palestinians

whats your evidence for this ?

>>> If you do not support Israel, you can't call yourself a communist.

whats your evidence for this ?

reply

Evidence? It is all very well documented in books, leftist newspapers, websites, wikipedia would be a good start.

reply

@ kimilseung
The OP might be a troll, but the first 2 statements you quote ("The german left, the anti-imperialists supported the islamic revolution in Iran" and "The got trained by the Fedajin. Anti semitic palestinians") are actually true and portrayed in this movie.
Also, I don't know if they knew it, but the palestinian training camps were in part financed by former Nazi supporters, which makes the situation very ironic since the RAF were claiming to fight against the new-fascism.

reply

"very ironic since the RAF were claiming to fight against the new-fascism."

RAF and their totalitarian Marxist puppetmasters WERE the "new fascism".

reply

I didn't know about this Horst Mahler fellow. Interesting. Kind of like why so many Neo Nazis are in the former East Germany and in post-Soviet Russia.

Which one is he in the movie?

reply

Maybe you're just not a very good communist then. Try Christianity?

1411 > 192

reply

"Maybe you're just not a very good communist then. Try Christianity?"

Oh Ć’ucking hell. Can we please stop recommending ways to be horrible to one another? Trading Stalin for God is kinda like swapping ebola for HIV.




"And no regrets?"

reply

What are you talking about? The left is againts Israel! They don't hate the jews, they just hate the Israeli state for being opressive towards Palestina and also because they are being muppets to USA.

reply

[deleted]

Fawk you

reply

Very rarely do trolls make me laugh. This is one of those times.

reply

I do appreciate a communist who opposes anti-Americanism. In fact, the general theories of Marxist-Leninism do not appear 'wicked' to me. It's the illogical anti-Americanism that pervades the Far Left that does.

Anti-Americanism is a mental disorder and I am not a "America-is-the-greatest-nation" type either.

reply

"In fact, the general theories of Marxist-Leninism do not appear 'wicked' to me."

Please explain how totalitarianism, enforced poverty and mass genocide are benevolent traits.

reply

You're not a communist. I don't know what you are but you aren't a communist. Communists don't support Israel's colonial race state, or US imperialism. So, as long as you support those things, stop calling yourself a communist.

"None are more hopelessly enslaved than those who falsely believe they are free."
- Goethe

reply

As a Communist I fully support Israel's colonial race state and US imperialism. You were saying?...

reply

1. Yes, most of the left supported the Iranian revolution to overthrow the Shah. Even Iranian communists. The events that followed had a large portion of the socialists in the country killed, women oppressed, and the implementation of sharia law. It's not something the left should be ashamed of. The Shah was an imperialist puppet and he had to go. The problem was the material conditions and contractions weren't fully considered. The state was based on religious repression and not class struggle.

2. "If you do not support Israel, you can't call yourself a communist." So if you don't support a US-backed Zionist state that's literally stealing Arab land, you're not a communist? I suggest you read some Marx.

3. There's a difference between anti-Americanism (whatever that means) and anti-Imperialism. If you WERE a communist, you'd understand that.

4. You're enemy should be the German right. The same German right that killed Luxemburg and Liebknecht. The same German right that allowed Nazis to rise to power, killing communists, socialists, union leaders, different races, and homosexuals. If you, once again, WERE, a communist, you'd have a sense of solidarity for your German comrades.

_________________________
LIVING IS A SELFISH ACT.
SURVIVAL IS A GENETIC LAW.

reply

Great post, sleepingbag.

"The people, and the people alone, are the motive force in the making of world history."
Mao

reply

Not, it's a freaking insane post on the same level as OP's post, only he's an obvious troll. But yeah, it was already clear you're cuckoo-for-cocoa-puffs...

reply

I, as a person whos childhood began in socialist country have no sympathy for communists.

reply