Am I the only one that had no problem with Gyllenhaal?

Miscast. A nerdy actor playing an action hero.

E.

I'm with you Shriek, I enjoyed him in this film

If you want to bash me CC me in a PM if you actually want me to see it :)

No, you're not the only one.

I admit I was nervous at first when I heard he was cast, but after seeing the film I think he fit the part quite well.

Nillindeiel

"She walks, you leave together, pockets full debts paid. She sings-you leave alone." ~Love Never Dies

He didn't completely convince me in the role, though he does have a likeable, cheeky charm if some of his reactions were off.
Maybe it was sometimes obvious his hair was partly extensions ... the whole thing felt like expensive cosplay, to me. Not horrid, but not anything special either.

She was like John Rambo meets Polly Pocket.

No, you are not the only one. I actually thought he was rather good. I was skeptical when I heard about his casting but he really did quite well.

[deleted]

I thought he was great, he looked the part and came across well. He obviously enjoyed it, too, and the amount of fun he was having came across which massively brightened his performance.

I went in with low hopes and came out of a rather decent film.

No my dear, procrastination is an art form!

I liked Jake as well because he reminds me of the videogame character.

"Tell me something, my friend.You ever dance with the devil in the pale moonlight? " Batman '89