Deserves alot more than a 4.5

It's not perfect, but a 4.5 is still too low. There's dozens of remakes that are worse than this. It knew it was a silly Xmas slasher and didn't try to be anything more. I find the original over rated and this one under rated honestly.

Yeah black Christmas 2006 was not a great movie but it’s still a pretty decent one.. it deserves a 6.3 score