MovieChat Forums > Looking for Comedy in the Muslim World (2006) Discussion > Why not go to the Muslim world instead o...

Why not go to the Muslim world instead of India in Asia?


Did not anyone stop Brooks and say hey bud (like the co-star Ms Sheetal Sheth, a Hindu); India is NOT a Muslim country but actually a HINDU country (officialy secular like the US) with almost 85% of the country as practicing Hindus? He did not go to the heart of the Muslim world, instead you went to a Hindu country in Asia.

Why didn’t he go to the Middle East or Africa? There many more Muslims in Africa and Middle East then there are in India?

Moreover he could have gone to Indonesia, and Malaysia in Southeast Asia where there are over 300 million Muslims, and yes they are East Asian looking (or more Chinese looking), but just like the millions of Muslims in the “stan” countries of central Asia, that’s the reality.

What Brooks et al did is worse then coming to America to study the Black world (there are 12% African Americans in the US which is the equivalent to the percentage of Muslims in India) or go to France to study the Muslim world (they have over 10% Muslims) or best yet he should have gone to Israel to study the Arab Palestinian Muslim world since Israel has a much higher percentage of Muslims then does India?

Why did he do this? The premise of the movie was to show how the US wants to learn about the Muslim world and dispel its ignorance to better deal with it. Yet he makes the ultimate ironic ignorant move and goes to a non-Muslim country counter to the title. Perhaps this was why Sony decided to stay away from this movie because the Title is wrong and a lie.

Why did Brooks, a Jew, do this? What he has done is a form of racism and not only does a disservice to Muslims but he has tried to detract from over a billion Hindus worldwide and in India. He shows women wearing their Bindis which is know world over that Hindus wear them and yet he tries to misrepresent those women as Muslims. Why?

Brooks simply ignored the facts and it seems he in particular but perhaps the West in general don’t care about accuracy and truth...simply lumping people together no matter the realities.

What America needs most is more accuracy and wider exposure to the myriads of peoples and religions that make up this world and not fraudulently misrepresented India and its majority Hindu people (as well as the turban wearing Sikhs) in the movie.

reply

India has the world's second largest Muslim Population after Indonesia... do your research before you write a big long rant and look like a fool.

reply

India may have a very large population of Muslims, but generally, it is not considered a Muslim country. So the title doesn't exactly match the movie. Some people here are overthinking things here. Forget about statistics, it's all about the general view of things.

With that aside, is the movie any good? I only saw the trailer online, and never even heard of it on Tv or at a theater.

reply

Because the Muslims in India at least have a sense of humor. Take it as a compliment.

reply

dude, if anyone as boring as albert brooks did stand up no one will laugh!

This is YOUR LIFE and it is ending one minute at a time!

reply

[deleted]

ghandi_rules08 '

Your *beep* post against muslims and Pakistan or whatever....shows your level of intelligence. ..and mind you ..I am an Indian...i dont practice any religion...but i do respect all religions and any other country...let it be even Pakistan ..so please *beep* off and dont insult the rest of us.....

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

its pretty simple actually, its coz the indian accent is the funniest. So weather the jokes in it were funny or not, the accent of some indians deff made a diff impact.

reply

[deleted]

There are more Muslims in eastern and southern Asia than in western Asia and northern Africa. Muslim and Arab are not necessarily synonymous.

Kenneth Rorie

reply

Ya man(replieing to the first comment), India does have a large Muslim country. It's all over places in the middle east. Check online about it. My step dad use to live there like 2 years ago man only in Iran. He's Muslim and he knows more than you I guess, but I can't believe you posted that. That post was just a comment that came to your head and I guess other people as well have proved you are horribly wrong better than me but man I have to laugh.

Check it out
http://imdb.com/title/tt0409182/usercomments-453

reply

its not a documentary.

al brooks asks about india being mostly hindi in the movie and they tell him if he can tell them what makes hindus laugh they'll consider it a success.

end of discussion.

reply