Not Historical


I feel the movie did not portray Smith historically. The goal of this movie was to tell Smith's life in a way that would be "comfortable" to the LDS Church leaders, historical accuracy seems to have been of little concern. The movie was designed to be a "faith promoting" experience, not a balanced view of Smith "as a man." I have taken it upon myself to study Smith's life and have read both LDS works and none LDS works. The movie, like most LDS projects, was beautifully filmed and well acted. However, this was not a realistic portrayal of either the beginnings of Mormonism or Smith's relatively short life.

A significant period of time was given to reenacting an accident that Smith had when he was seven. While this event was no doubt important in forming his mental outlook, it appears that the main reason for including it in the film is to help establish a sympathetic view of Joseph Smith. Another point is in portraying Smith's teen years the film is silent regarding the Smith family's involvement in magical practices during the 1820's. Another problem is while the movie shows Joseph Smith good-naturedly entering into wrestling contests, it fails to show how he sometimes lost his temper and became violent.

I could go on and on. This movie was not historical in any way and should be considered a fictional movie about a man. I would not recommend seeing this movie for any other purpose other then entertainment.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Your absolutely correct in your accusations on this film. My wife's high school friend is Mormon and she and her husband invited us to Old Town California to watch this film with them. They cried of course and I was confused. When I got home I was curious as to why Joseph Smith was so amazing and what EXACTLY it was that he did. I did some REAL research on him, not some close minded Mormon research but some real insight as to what Joseph Smith was really like. And true as it was, he was kind and giving but at the same time his teachings were ridiculously out there. I mean do Mormons really believe that God was human at some point? All my life with REAL scriptures dating back hundreds and hundreds of years, I always thought God had no beginning. Then Smith all of a sudden decides that God was once human? Really? I'm supposed believe this? And lets not even get started on polygamy and his marrying of two 14-year old girls because God "told" him to.
At the same time I understand why the movie would leave out so much. Its like the Catholic Church funding a movie that says God isn't real. Why would the Mormon Church release aa TRUE ACCURATE movie based on Joseph Smith.

reply