MovieChat Forums > Suburban Girl (2007) Discussion > Simply Irresistible or Sububan girl?

Simply Irresistible or Sububan girl?


Which one of SMG's romantic comedies do you prefer?

Simply irresistible or Suburban Girl?

reply

Simply Irresistible, hands down.

The hardest thing in this world is to live in it.

reply

Oh my stars, Suburban Girl!! I can barely remember Simply, I saw it on my bday whatever year it came out. My friend loved it, I just have a vague sense of wanting more....something.

This film was missing something also, but I always get lost in the perfect soundtrack and the lovely way it was shot. I don't know that I would even call SG a rom-com, it's more slice-of-life to me. Well, if I had an impossibly fabulous place in the fabulous City :)

I so hope Sarah's next TV project does well. We know she can act, I think she just doesn't make great choices. Or her agent doesn't.


Any thoughts of a better casting for Archie? I do have trouble getting past Alec being so shlubby and her being attracted to him - i need to read the books sometime.

reply