Cassie or Ella?


Personally I liked Cassie more, she had better chemistry with Thelma and she was more fun to watch. What do you think?

"I can resist everything except temptation." - Oscar Wilde.

reply

Ella 100% she was great but i did like Cassie and cryed when she died :(

reply

Ella for me too. She's just great, and she has more depth then Cassie.

Buffy: Oh, I'm not really into porn. I mean, I'm just trying to cut way back.

reply

Ella, I liked how she was a flawed hero and how we saw her relationship with Thelma grow over time, Ella and Leon were cute too.

Cassie never really grew on me when she left I really didn't feel a difference in the show.

"Why are you wearing that stupid man suit?" - Frank

reply

Well I was starting to like Cassie in Season 1 then when Ella came in Season 2, I liked her more because she is more exciting to watch, her fight scenes are a lot more interesting than Cassie crying and sitting in her room!

"Where you born this big a pain in the ass?" -Buffy

reply

I agree, Ella brought action to this show.

reply

Cassie.

Ella came, and the whole series sped up too much.

I liked that Cassie was just discovering everything, but Ella's 500 year-old-character seems to make too many mistakes. It's just hard to empathise with a character that inhuman, which came in to replace an incredibly humane character.

reply

[deleted]

I kind of liked both, cassie was perfect in season 1 and ella's the perfect girl for season 2... but since i prefer season 1 i'd vote for cassie :-)

reply

agreed.. when Ella was on I ended up just getting confused cos it seemed like so much random stuff was happening really fast

reply

I vote for Cassie!

reply

Cassie.

Ella is like a mary-sue. And just like all the other "chosen one" characters out there. *yawn*

Cassie's story is better.

reply

I loved Cassie and I think that you could relate alot more to her than ella. When Cassie died, Ella didnt really fill the void. I mean shes good... I loved the episode where shes in the asylum with the fairy, but she never really did ity as well as cassie. Plus Cassie and Azazeal were like THE couple on Hex, and after she lef the show, it just wasnt the same.

reply

I gotta say i luv cassie and i`ve only seen 2 episodes i like ella so much just from hearing about her and thelmas great too

heres my idea how come cassie couldn`t have stayed alive and teamed up with ella it would have been great those two and unstoppable force oh well i like them both

reply

Why did Cassie's character get killed off?

reply

No i dont like ella as much as Cassie...Cassie should have stayed forever!

reply

i perfer cassie as well

reply

You really think that she was a mary sue? Hmph. I'm not sure what I think. I think anyone can be accused of this.

Security Officer: "Want to negotiate a landing fee?"
Boba: "Want to negotiate an ion cannon?"

reply

I adored both, but I think if I had a gun to my head and had to choose (not that that situation would ever arise) I would have to pick Ella. She is gorgeous and fun to watch. Cassie is too, but Ella moreso. And she was more adept with her powers which made her even more fun to watch :P

reply

Cassie = SMOKING!

reply

Cassie. I like Ella, but I just enjoyed Cassie's character more. The show changed a lot when she left (not a bad change, just different).

>~~~<
http://z13.invisionfree.com/Radiant_Gardens/ <~Forum for "happy" people (and friends of "happy" people) who also really enjoy [video] gaming, movies, televison, and fun discussions. Stop on by! =)

reply

Ella was definitely cool and interesting, but for someone who is centuries old, she made a lot of rookie teenager mistakes, which didn't make much sense to me

reply


I liked Ella a bit more, mostly because her and Leon were so adorable.

Plus Leon PWNS them all.

reply

Cassie. She was adorable!

reply

It has to be Ella for me. I saw Cassie as a horrible character. At first I did like Cassie then she just turned to be a character that always thought about herself, such as saying something similar to the lines "You want me, but I don't want you" it felt like that is the type of character that she was. But honestly I have to say I love Thelma and the actress who plays her <(=^_^=)>

reply

i loved cassie i really can't stand Ella
the show would be better if cassie comes back do you know if ther will be a third season of hex i just love the show

reply

One word..Cassie, Ella only became interesting when Malachi showed up.

"Wether you think you can or you think you can't - you're right"

reply

i would definetly pick ella... im not saying i hate cassie ...b cuz i tink she's ok, but thats just it shes "ok". on the other hand ella is more out there, she gives more action!... cassie shes too emotional...

1st season ... was kinda bad.. but wen ella came in it just got a lot beta

anywayz i prefare ella ovr cassie ..

Q: does any1 hav a video episodes of season 2? cnt find it anywhere???
if u have season 2 episodes plz reply 2 me!! (thankz)

reply

Id have to say Ella is my favorite for several reasons.
First, she kicks lots of ass.
Second, she's way better looking.
Third, better actress.
Fourth, Leon owns.

I could come up with more, but that's enough reasons for me.

Anyone know if they're doing a third season? Or do I have to write hate mail to writters, producers, companies... etc.

reply

I will have to say that I like both Cassie and Ella.

I would have liked to see Cassie live and become friends with Ella and maybe worked together. Though there was a bond with the child, if she had lived she could have helped his human side to be more effective and influiental. She was also just exploring her powers and then before her character was really developed, they just wipped her out of the show. There could have been more interesting plots if she had stayed or something.

reply

I've only seen Ella in one episode and already I like her better than Cassie. I say this because Cassie even with her powers comes off as a victim, where you really don't know where Ella is as far as the hero scale is concerned. Secondly, Ella has an air of mystery about her that Cassie does not.

reply

I liked Ella more. Laura Pypers an amazing actress and Ella has so much more depth and spirit to Cassie I think. She's been through so much more and is someone who hs such an interesting backstory and has so many conflicting emotions. She's tough but vulnerable, independent but she loves Leon so much. It's deffinately got to be Ella for me.

reply

I like them both, but with Cassie dead, I feel let down. There was so much more backstory that they didn't give us, that they could have. It probably would have made the series alot better, if they'd actually gave us a little more background story on Cassie, than what we got.

reply

I like Ella and Thelma and Leon.
I thought Cassie character was boring. When she got killed, I was hoping that she wouldn't come back so Ella can lead the show.

reply

Definitely Ella. There's a rich, extensive backstory there, and it's a shame it won't be tapped more. Plus Lura Pyper is incredible - those drugged / torture scenes in episode 4 were mesmerising to watch, with Laura demonstrating a power and range that went beyond anything that SMG or Billie Piper were given the opportunity to do in their respective shows.

The "grey" nature of her character, and her initial ruthlesseness, made her quite an unusual lead - although she does make some quite questionable (and, given her backstory, illogical) choices later on.

reply

Yes, the torture scenes where she just looks around wildly, screams and writhes about - my nieces and nephews do that, and more convincingly, I might add. The torturous part was having to watch a young actor try to portray a feeling with which is compoletely unaware and incapable of communicating. Ergo, I disagree with your assessment that Pyoer's performance was better than Gellar's. Admittedly, SMG is not by any stretch a good actress at all. It should speak volumes that Pyper can't act well enough to pretend disappointment when she doesn't get a tip after washing Gellar's car.

SOME questionalbe and illogical choices?? Dude, everyone in this series stands out as having their characters given every possible chance at making the proper decision, and even so far as to actually make a plan as to what to do, and then go and do the friggin' exact opposite thing. Am I the only one creeped out that a 400 year old demon-hunter was bumping uglies with a 6 month old grown fetal demonspawn? Gahhh! Too creepy, too creepy. Er, maybe that is some odd English thing, though. I am not sure..

reply

I would say Ella. Cassie is quite a bland character to be a female lead. The supporting character of Thelma was twice as interesting as Cassie.

The show lacked a mainstream audience, and the introduction of Ella tried to reach out to that audience. It speed up the pace, brought a iconic image that people could identify with. The image of Cassie is just not a marketable image, though Thelma, Ella and Roxanne are.

To be fair though, the two characters and their respective seasons are completely different. It is best to view them as separates. So really it is a preference between the style of Series 1 and Series 2.

Ella brought what the show lacked to be successful, which was a sense of action. Rather than melodramatics set to a supernatural theme, though series 2 did have its fair share. My only problem was that the action scenes were at times poorly executed. The Sariel chase scene led up to a predictable ending, where the demon died pretty quickly, probably too quickly. However they are a nice interlude.

Anyways the Ella and Malachi/Cassie and Azazel thing isn't that unusual. Its very familiar with the Buffy and Angel relationship, Buffy hooked up with a living corpse, isn't that a bit wrong? I'm pretty sure its illegal in some countries.

How boring would the show be if the characters didn't make the wrong choices. Anyways choice is up to the individual, it depends on what they see through their perspective.

Anyways back to the question. I would definately say Ella, mainly cause she isn't the victim that Cassie was.

reply

The show lacked a mainstream audience because it had no cohesive and continuing plot, although it did posess socially irredeemable characters. When Cassie's character left the show (the actor's decision, if the rumors are correct), the producers and writers decided that the smart plotlines tied to a main character were just not as profitable as a more action-oriented plot. Action is not supposed to be an interlude. A series is supposed to set a tone, and then FOLLOW that tone, so as to create a distinct fingerprint for the show. It would be like Boston Legal turning into a John Woo shoot-em-up, or a Buffy episode suddenly taking a turn for the worse and adding a laugh track. You create a tone and you stick with it.

However, it never seemed to do this, and miserly choices made it worse not better. It was simply one catastrophic decision after another by the producers and writers, beginning with the casting of a chubby, late-20's something anf giving her a fashion unconscious wardrobe, a bad haircut and worse makeup. A lead actor in a series is supposed to appeal to a wide range of folks (ergo the term lead), and that means choosing someone who is either very attractive and personable, or very talented. You cannot skimp here, because a failure of the lead to carry the show means the certain death of the show. Ella Dee was not such a character. She was over 400 years old, and was supposed to have gotten over all the teen angst and insanely bad personal choices. Yet, she didn't, and that - almost more than anything - drove me up the wall, across the ceiling, and down the other wall.

Using the excuse that Buffy did it to justify an immortal demon-hunter sleeping with her specified enemy is pathetic. For a show that wants to set itself apart from the strong comparisons with Buffy, they certainly toed the line on that one. The premise of the show was a burgeoning witch (Cassie) learnign to fight off prophecy and the advances of the demon Azazel. That this premise was dropped like a steaming turd almost immediately after the show started was a jump the shark moment, and cause for shutting down production.

"How boring would the show be if the characters didn't make the wrong choices. Anyways choice is up to the individual, it depends on what they see through their perspective."

Wht the previous poster failed to recognize is that the characters in Hex weren't supposed to easily make the right choices, tempted as they were from all sides. They were supposed to make the right choice after agonizing with it for a long time. However, in Hex, the characters always made the WRONG choice, which was maddening and boring and unrealistic. No one makes the wrong choice all the time. While choice is dependent upon the individual, members of soceity are aware - through constant culturization - what the correct range of choices are. The characters NEVER make the right choices. Darwin says that animals that make the wrong choices in development do not flourish. He was right; Hex was gone after only two seasons.

I still say Cassie, because the actor was more attractive, and she started out having an actual plot to back up her actions.

reply

She was also just exploring her powers and then before her character was really developed, they just wipped her out of the show
=============

THEY didn't whip/wipe her off the show, Christina Cole CHOSE to leave herself, presumably to further her career

reply