Very disturbing scene....


Okay so...

The movie is hard.. the story is bad, but one scene is horrific.

At least IMHO.

The one where the kid gets out of his bed and walks crying to his dead mothers hands -distrubing and raw...

For this scene I congratulate the director, it made my heart stop for a bit (yeah.. Im still a human)

I dont know if any other scene was disturbing for anyone else, plz leave your opinions.

To the director: Yup, the 9/11 scenes are crap.......! Those inserts are, for my point of view, out of context.

Cheers!

reply

The child is obviously in very real distress. It's inexcusable to a) film that distress and b) put it in a movie for no other reason than to shock.

Most young people (by which I mean under-30s) are still trying to test their own emotional limits. As the years go by, and life's little lessons accumulate, a maturing individual will have experienced - or those dear to her/him will have experienced - enough horror and fear in real life to engender a change in tastes; a horror fan will indeed, hopefully, remain a horror fan for life, but s/he will begin to become very discriminating about the subject matter and above all the way it's treated.
Extreme horror, as dear old Ebert once said, is fine, but M-S-P isn't extreme horror. Nor is it an exercise in deliberate bad taste. It's simply an attempt to shock made by a 'fim-maker' who is clueless about the necessity for atmosphere, mood, identification with/sympathy for well-written characters, and the need for intelligent dialog.

Repeat: well-written characters and intelligent dialog.

reply

This movie was the prerequisite for a bizzare satanic occult ritual in my town where the defendants claimed to be possessed by demonic forces,bizzare *beep*

reply

I haven't seen the movie in years, so maybe I'm forgetting something or I missed the point. But why were random 9/11 scenes thrown in anyway?

"I'll go,because I am Cinema!" - Ben (Man Bites Dog)

reply