MovieChat Forums > The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning (2006) Discussion > I like it a lot more than the 2003 remak...

I like it a lot more than the 2003 remake


The brutality, the sense of character...everything about it just sort of works better than the remake, in my opinion.

I also like the ending a lot more. The ending to this film has guts, it's like a punch in the stomach in a good way...the ending to the remake was just sort of the typical 'final girl' ending.

PACIFIC RIM
JULY 12th, 2013

reply

I totally agree with you there. The 2003 remake was pretty good and all, but The Beginning 2006 tops any Chainsaw Massacre movie out there even the 1974 version.

One thing about the 2003 movie, I wish they had chosen to keep the alternate ending.

reply

With the interview with Erin, the main character? I don't know...I wasn't really a fan of that.

But then again I wasn't really a fan of that movie in general.

PACIFIC RIM
JULY 12th, 2013

reply

Yeah I thought the interview was interesting. The movie was ok. I did like the end when Erin owned Hewitt and Hoyt then escaped.

But nothing compares to The beginning. The best one of them all. I do know the 3-d new release is coming out in January, but it's no relation to 2003 and 2006 TCM. It's related to the 1974 version. Do you think they will make another related to TCM 2003 and 2006? I don't see how they could without Hoyt or a one armed Hewitt.

reply

Nah, I doubt it.

Either the 3D film, which is a direct sequel to the original 74 film, is going to be a success and get sequels of it's own

OR it fails, a few years go by, and we get another remake or reboot.

If The Beginning had been more of a hit(it was successful, just not on the level of the 03 version) then the plan was to do films that took place between it and the 03 film. That's not going to happen now.

I would have liked to see one about the girl at the beginning of the 03 film, one about her that ends with the scene of her getting picked up and killing herself. I thought that would have been interesting.

PACIFIC RIM
JULY 12th, 2013

reply

"I would have liked to see one about the girl at the beginning of the 03 film, one about her that ends with the scene of her getting picked up and killing herself. I thought that would have been interesting."


I totally agree with you on that. And even to see more of the story from 1969 to 1973 after Chrissie was killed from nearly escaping. As great as The Beginning was, there could have been so much more done with 03 where they lacked. But I think the ending of Hoyt's career in 03, and 1 armed Hewitt pretty much ruins the idea of another sequel.

I don't have too much of a good feeling about the 3-D film. But I could be wrong.

reply

Yeah...part of the reason The Beginning is the only one I own...it ends the story in a better place, in my opinion.

I'm not too sure about TCM 3D either...I mean, it could be good. But the concept of ignoring all of the previous films but being a direct sequel to the original film from 74 could end up being commercial suicide.

I mean, very few children of the 90s have probably even seen the original film, I have, but I'm a rarity.

And THAT generation is the one that is making up a huge chunk of the moviegoing public...so making a sequel to a film that is 38 years old isn't exactly the best idea.

To modern audiences, the 03 and 06 film are the only version of TCM they know.

They'd be better off doing another remake, to be honest.

PACIFIC RIM
JULY 12th, 2013

reply

Agreed with you there.

reply

But nothing compares to The beginning. The best one of them all

i loved this when it came out. i saw this in theaters and jumped so many times lol WAY better than the remake and more R. Lee Ermey as well. Sheriff Hoyt is the ultimate bad guy!!!

reply

The Beginning is far better than the remake in my opinion.

I can't stand that scene in the remake where Erin actually drinks the tea from the suspicious ladies(Groans)

"See it with someone you love...Go by yourself"

reply

I prefer this one as well. I don't know why, I just like it better.

"Give a hand to my band, Sexual Chocolate!" Coming to America

reply

The Beginning kicks major A$$!! The Backstory, Hewitt and Hoyt were just epic! Even R. Lee Ermey in an interview mentioned he enjoyed acting in this one rather than the remake.

http://www.phen375review.webs.com

reply

I prefer the original. This one was like a boring version of the remake, it was too similar to it.

reply

[deleted]

Hear, hear!
I don't mean to impose, but I am the Ocean.

reply

It's my favorite of the series! :)
The gore and brutality were a LOT better, as was the atmosphere and cinematography. And I agree, the ending was really shocking (Though I admit to wishing that Dean and Chrissie swapped roles in those last few secodns... It's no biggie, but would make it stand out a LOT more to me! Plus, Dean is my favorite of the entire series. Seeing him go would heartbreak me more than Chrissie)

It has some of the best characters of the series too :)
Dean and Eric <3

Death Awaits you (Horror forum)
http://w11.zetaboards.com/Death_Awaits/index/

reply

It's definitely much more brutal and gory, but that doesn't make it a better film.

I just watched it again last night, and while I think it's an okay film, it's nowhere near as good as the 2003 film. So many stupid, stupid things happen in this. Characters make such idiotic decisions and at some points, I can't help but roll my eyes.

Overall, I like the movie, but I hate how I have to suspend so much disbelief when a character gets thrown out of a speeding, tumbling car and is perfectly fine after the fact.

reply

I believe the characters is the absolute WEAKEST argument against it. The characters in the Beginning are far better than the ones in the remake, especially Dean and Eric.

Also, I'd like to point out that Erin has to be one of the dumbest horror heroines of all time. She gets everyone in the entire movie killed by FORCING them to do what she wants with the hitchhiker situation, she just abandons Andy to die, she sits and watches as Leatherface runs down Pepper, and, worst of all, she sits and watches as Leatherface fights with Morgan. After Leatherface DROPPED his chainsaw. She deserved a grisly death

Death Awaits you (Horror forum)
http://w11.zetaboards.com/Death_Awaits/index/

reply

I really liked the the 2006 one, to me it was by far the best of the series. Although Jessica biel ass shots make the 2003 one worth watching =P

reply

I love the 2003 as well. And yeah, Jessica Biel had a killer body. Her character sucked though; Erin was an awful heroine :(

Nice to see someone else who liked the 2006 one :)

Death Awaits you (Horror forum)
http://w11.zetaboards.com/Death_Awaits/index/

reply


I just watched the 2003 version last night and even though I like it just slightly better than 2006 version, I totally agree about Erin. I was literally watching it and could not believe how I did not notice all the terrible decisions she made before. After seeing that I agree totally that she is one of the dumbest and most useless heroines of all time, and that's saying something.


Haters gonna hate

reply

I just finished this one, it's slightly better than the 2003 film but still pretty bad.

reply

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2003 is the best! I reckon The Beginning is up there. Very good prequel. I was actually surprised by its quality.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]