MovieChat Forums > The Kite Runner (2008) Discussion > Do you think this movie was propaganda t...

Do you think this movie was propaganda to justify America's war


It's hard to believe that a country is so sick. Talibans are humans after all..

Do you think that they really rape kids when they are horny, kill women with stones, sell legs on the street, have people hung...

reply

It's hard to believe that a country is so sick. Talibans are humans after all..

The OP is so naiive.
It don't matter squat what we all here do believe, all it matters is how it IS.
And it is just like that and even worse.
So my friend go to the church, light a candle and praise the Lord that you have the luxury to afford wondering if to believe or not, and you don't have the experience of living with such people and such country in your life.
And you praise him and thank all that US and EU guys that went there and secured some little peace in this forlorn and forsaken place.
Talibans need to be taught a lesson in humanity, they need to see themselves for what they really are - totally inhumane.

reply

As an Afghan woman, some of these replies are seriously pissing me off. I know a lot of these comments were posted in 2009 or so, but the racism and ignorance some of you guys have about Afghanistan is startling. You guys do realize Afghanistan was NOT always like this, right? We are not "savages" or "tribal people who have always killed each other". It wasn't until the Soviet Occupation of Afghanistan when everything spiraled out of control and nothing was ever the same again. However, before the Soviet Occupation, Afghanistan was actually quite a beautiful country and my parents have always shared with me the fond memories they have of our home country (pre-Soviet invasion). Here are some pictures of Afghanistan before the Soviet War (these were compiled by the Denver Post and The Atlantic):
http://tinyurl.com/ashbf8z
http://tinyurl.com/owmcmgg
- Note: I'm going to put some these links in "tiny url" because some of the original ones are way too long.

To the person who said "the war in Afghanistan was absolutely justified", umm no, actually it wasn't. Seriously, I'm sick of people calling the war in Afghanistan "the good war" or "the justified war". There was nothing justifiable about it! Here is why: http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20020201.htm
Both the Iraq War and the war in Afghanistan were horrible and should have never happened, so please stop saying that the Afghan one was "the good one".

As for the person who said something along the lines of "What would the US want from Afghanistan? That country has nothing but poppies." You are so painfully ignorant and naive. Afghanistan has many natural resources (such as lithium, which Afghanistan has a vast amount of) and also natural gasses. In my opinion, the real reason why the US and NATO are in Afghanistan is for these minerals and pipelines. Read this article: http://tinyurl.com/9gzj58a

Furthermore, the US is also occupying Afghanistan for its geopolitical location. The fact that Afghanistan borders countries like Iran, China, Pakistan, and isn't that far away from India and Russia is no doubt considered an advantage from America's point of view. Read this for more information: http://tinyurl.com/qxh96f3- Note: I really recommend this site (RAWA), it is run by Afghan women.

Here is another good read about the US occuption of Afghanistan, and it is written by an Afghan woman: http://tinyurl.com/q6dxsfk

Another good read about the US occupation: http://tinyurl.com/n9a7h7j

So long story short, some of you guys really need to think before you post and make sure you actually know what you're talking about.

reply

Yeah. God forbid there are people who are oppressed by America's enemy. Who cares about them.

If this movie is about white enslave blacks, or priest molest children, you will buy them.
But god forbid this movie is about the atrocity committed by Talibans. It is so hard for you to swallow.

reply

This thread proves how naive and ignorant you are. These atrocities are not even news to anyone. And yet you found it is hard to believe.
You found it is hard to believe only because it doesn't fit your agenda.

Screw those who are oppressed by Talibans, we want movies about all whites are evil slave owners and all Christians are haters. Movies about actual evil people being evil will offend these liberals.

reply