MovieChat Forums > Brødre (2004) Discussion > Opinions from 'non-danes'

Opinions from 'non-danes'


If you're not from Denmark, what do you think of Brothers?

In Denmark we're always told how great danish movies are doing in foreign countries. Since only 500 votes have been registered at IMDB, I was wondering whether that's true.

Choose between the hollywood-drama and a film in a language you've not often heard. What is your choise?

I think it is confusing to watch a movie in a language I'm not familiar with. Even though I've got german in school, I don't watch german films a lot.



There is so much beauty in the world

reply

I am an American married to a Swede, so we see all Scandinavian films that we can. I really didn't like this film at all, because I kept thinking, "This would never happen!" I just don't think the events in Afghanistan were at all realistic, and the man's reactions were also not believable (not to mention the fact that he apparently got no counseling or "debriefing" at all). And I don't think a 7 or 8 year old child would exclaim at the family dinner table, "Mom ****ed Uncle John" (or whatever his name was). I was sitting in the theater rolling my eyes about one-third of the way into the film to the end. To ask yourself, "After such and such, would this happen?" is irrelevant, when the first "triggering" event is not realistic. Two thumbs down on this one!

reply

To Lisaane -->

You must really not like a lot of films then?

How many film's aren't non-realistic?

In my opinion you have to interpret this as a worst scenario case!

And how much do we really know about the wars out there?
How much is hidden from us by the governments leading these wars?

Sorry, but your world must be really dull if you are that blind or should we say "realistic"...

reply

She probably feels like me, I hate all the Dogme 95 movies I've seen. They're not realistic, but pretends to be. Their idea of being profound is pounding the audience over the head with extreme emotion and overdone negativity. Danish movies are all more or less Dogme-inspired now, so I've just given up on Danish movies.

For the record I love the movies of Truffaut, Rohmer, Melville (yeah I've seen a lot of French movies lately), Bunuel, Takeshi Kitano, Wong Kar-wai, Lynch, Cronenberg, Wenders, Jarmusch, Aki Kaurismäki... others, but I'll stop there. I'm Norwegian by the way.

reply

Violent COP!

reply

I saw it last year at the Filmfest in Hamburg and I absolutely loved it. But I love all the films that have "Anders Thomas Jensen" somewhere in the credits. ;-)

But you were asking about how we rate watching foreign language films. Since in Germany everything is dubbed, we don't have this "problem". People still get more attracted by big Hollywood productions featuring big movie stars, which is extremely sad.

I personally don't have a problem "reading" a movie and I prefer the actors' own voices. Especially in Danish since I love the sound of the language, but that's just me. :-P But here you have to "hunt" for screenings in the original language.

reply


I'm from CA, I got done watching this movie a half hour ago and I loved it.

I've been watching a lot of Danish films for the past couple of weeks (hurray for Netflix) and I always felt refreshed after watching them. I started getting into it because I saw Mads Mikkelsen in King Arthur and thought he was really good. So I watched some of his movies, and Nikolaj Lie Kaas was in a lot of them, and I thought he was really good too. So now I've just been browsing through them all.

I was just saying to my friend the other day that it seems like foreign films have better portrayals of the characters and plots in general because there isn't a lot of special effects and big Hollywood crap going on in the background.

This movie was really good. When I read the plot I thought to myself: Okay, the brother and wife are going to end up in bed. But all that happened between them was a kiss. If it had been Hollywood there would have been some raunchy sex scenes. Case closed.

Also other foreign films: Open Hearts, Flickering Lights, The Green Butchers, Shake it all About, Wilbur wants to Kill Himself, Pusher. Although I know some of these didn't do too well in Denmark, I certainly enjoyed them anyway.

Subtitles don't bother me either. I'd take that over a dubbed movie anyday. I always have close captioning on my TV anyway, so it's all the same to me.

Because I could not stop for Death, He kindly stopped for me...

reply

My sisters and I ended up ordering this movie on PPV on accident. So, we sat through and watched it. And I must say that we really enjoyed it. It invoked such powerful emotions upon us, that at one point I seriously had to leave the room. Not that the movie was annoyin me, it was just that I couldn't handle it. Which really makes the movie such a great one. Sometimes I don't get the way 'Hollywood' works. Such intense, magnificent movies such as this are hadly well known... but trashy, corny, stupid movies get rave reviews and a lot of publicity. Oy Vey.

-Kerry The Pirate

reply

I'm from Spain, and I really loved this movie. I was very imprressed by Ulrich Thomsen's performance. Like other reviewer, I was so affected by the movie that I need to leave the room one moment (guees when).

I have seen a lot of Scandinavian Films and my average opinion is that I love/hate 50% of your movies. I hate Dogma,Trier and his followers(except two or maybe three movies)because they think they are a gift from God to us, poor stupid morons that don't know what is the TRUE cinema.

The rest of the Scandinavian films are ussually very good, like the rest of the other great european cinematographies.

Forgive my poor english.

reply

I am an American who watches five to six films per week, foreign and non - almost always on DVD. If the movie is good, subtitles don't bother me a bit. I thought that Brothers was a powerful film, one of the best I have seen in the past year. It had many emotional layers and excellent acting, especially by Connie Nielsen and the two male leads. A film's style seems to be less important to me than its complexity and characters. This film deserves more attention world wide.

reply

I live in a midwest state in the US. Most of the films that I watch are foreign films. I am a huge fan of Dogme films--especially Lars Von Trier. I have seen many of his films and some of favorite films include Idiots, Breaking the waves, Dancer in the Dark, and Dogville. I thought that Brothers was a good movie with an interesting plot. However, I thought that it was not of the level of some of the other Dogme films. I found Ulrich Thomsen's performance in Celebration much more compelling that in Brothers. The reversal of the roles of the two brothers could have been better handled.

I have to admit that I saw brothers a day after I saw Ingmar Bergman's Scenes from a marriage (a master piece indeed!), which may have made me downgrade this movie (brother) a bit:)

reply

I am an American living in Arizona. I loved this film. Everthing about it was well done.

I do watch a lot of foreign films. I have found that they rely on stories that focus on human emotions rather than things blowing up and exploding non-stop such as you find in many (but not all) Hollywood films.

I am a history buff and love period films. I am especially interested in the Second World War. I much prefer European films that cover this period of history over American films that are WWII based. Somehow European films do a much better job of conveying the human side of war (with some notable exceptions) than a lot of American WWII based films have done in the past. I also like seeing perspectives of the war presented from other countries viewpoints.

I am also very fond of romantic British period dramas. The refined and cultured acting is always so refreshing and most of them have romantic happy endings which I just love.

Some of my favorite foreign films include Sara, Zelary, Dark Blue World, and Kolya. My favorite all-time film from ANY country is Sara. This is a Polish film starring the great Boguslaw Linda as the bodyguard of a mob-bosses' beautiful daughter. Although in one sense this film does try to emulate American action films, it carries a unique element that is all its own. I've lent my copy to many of my friends and I have yet to have anyone tell me they disliked it. The comment I get is usually something along the lines of "There's just a different feel about it than in most American films."

Now, having said all this, please don't let me give the impression that I distain all things Hollywood in favor of any film made outside the USA. There are many great American films and there are also a lot of foreign films I have seen that have been very poor.



reply

I'm from Canada.

A couple of years ago I got sick of the usual Hollywood movies that usually flood the mainstream cinemas. So I started going to indie art houses and seeing more foreign films. Open Hearts (another amazing film by Susanne Bier) was one of the first foreign films I saw. I just recently had a chance to rent Brothers and I loved it. Excellent job by all the actors and an excellent script which really examined family realtionships.

Anyway to answer your second question I'd probably choose a foreign film rather then a Hollywood film. Usually in order for a foreign film to find it's way to North American theatres it has to be the cream of the crop. Most foreign films that are screened over here have won numerous festivals and have been oscar nominated. Besides, I don't mind subtitles at all and if the films are in French or Spanish I can generally understand them fairly well even without the subtitles.

reply

I'm from the Netherlands, and I really love Scandinavian movies. The acting is generally really top notch, and the characters and events are so much easier to relate to than the average American film. The characters and the stories just seem so much more familiar than with a US film. Which doesn't mean I don't like American films by the way, it's just that, being from the Netherlands, Scandinavia is a lot more familiar. :)

This movie was an excellent example; I really thought it was great.

reply

I´m from Colombia. As all over the world, the Hollywood industry controls all the distribution channels. 30 years ago, we could see the last Truffaut films the year after their release in France. Today, very few european (or, in general, non-american) films are shown.

We normally have no problems with subtitles, because almost every film has them.

Yesterday I saw Brothers. It's spanish name is Verdades ocultas (Hidden truths). I really liked this film. I dont remember having seen a danish film before.





reply