MovieChat Forums > I, Robot (2004) Discussion > Yeah Asimov wouldnt have liked this adap...

Yeah Asimov wouldnt have liked this adaptation


yeah dont think he wouldve like this adaptation as its largely untrue to the book.

reply

You can't even call it an adaptation. It's more like "inspired by, with a few vague references to some of the stories". That being said, it's still a very well made, entertaining movie, just not really based on the book it's named after.

reply

The plot has nothing to do with any of the robot stories he wrote, and I think he'd have hated that the robots were essentially the villains.

reply