Amy would have never got into Harvard or Princeton

No person in the history of either university has got in with failing grades their junior year. Especially someone who only got a bottom quartile SAT score who stopped doing her extra-curricular's for 2 years for boys. At least have her get a 1600 on the SATs or something if you're going to pretend she has the possibility of getting in. Even then it's impossible, but at least it's not stupid.