MovieChat Forums > Open Range (2003) Discussion > Bad Foley work (Duvall eating the chocol...

Bad Foley work (Duvall eating the chocolate)

posted 13 years ago by Lukeh4
15 replies | jump to latest

Late in the film, when Duvall buys the chocolate bar and begins eating it, you can hear an audible snap each time he takes a bite. Now, it looked to me that the grocer just had the bar in his display case; I didn't see a freezer. And yet for chocolate to be audibly masticated, it would have to be quite hard, as it might be when frozen. It's all the more silly when the preceding dialogue was all about how it was smooth and "melts in your mouth".

Why the director and editor decided to leave this Foley work in the film is odd. Maybe they just overlooked it. And I know it's not really a major point (to understate things). It just annoyed me when I watched it. It sound like Duvall is chomping down on a candy cane, not savoring a chocolate bar.

[–] jules_03 13 years ago

This is literally the least important thing I've ever read on the internet.

[–] Jetfire1959 8 years ago

This is literally the least important thing I've ever read on the internet.

I'd say your reply has that title wrapped up.

May The Force Be With You As You Live Long & Prosper🎸

[–] mezwestrope 13 years ago

A thick bar of bittersweet, dark chocolate does snap when you bite into it.

What is YOUR final destination in this journey through life?

[–] artistathome 13 years ago

I swear, are the posters here all about 13 years old or what? Give. me. a. break...

Stop asking such dumb questions and keying on stupid things like a frickin candy bar.

That just proves there is NOTHING wrong with this movie.

Honestly, in the last few years it has been on constantly!!

[–] Jetfire1959 8 years ago

Stop asking such dumb questions and keying on stupid things like a frickin candy bar.

The OP has the right to post whatever he wants as long as it's not obscene. If you don't like it, DON'T READ IT

May The Force Be With You As You Live Long & Prosper🎸

[–] madmadrid 13 years ago

I was wondering why a general store in a small town in the middle of the prarie would even sell expensive imported Swiss chocolate.Other than that this is one of my favorite westerns ever.

[–] ta2me92704 12 years ago

I was wondering why a general store in a small town in the middle of the prarie would even sell expensive imported Swiss chocolate.

Because a traveling salesman sold them some.

The thorn defends the rose, yet it is peaceful and does not seek conflict.

[–] Standard_Leisure 13 years ago

I guess you've never had a high quality dark chocolate bar before.

[–] Nikon11 13 years ago

I really like that scene, Duvall trying it, and then giving the storekeeper a piece. I like the snap too - and I don't even like chocolate.

[–] justmeetee 13 years ago

Maybe that's what a stale chocolate bar sounded like 130 years ago. Let's ask someone that was there. Oh wait....

signature must be fewer then 100 characters in length

[–] rickyhatton 12 years ago

erm, i quite like this post, i think its a valid point. It's my understanding that these forums are for discussion on all things screen related and foley artists are very important to the process.

I thought that in the film boss spearman and charley waite had arrived in town at an autumn (fall) period and that would have brought colder temperatures with it, especially so close to the mountains so for me the chocolate would have been quite hard and "snappy" until it "melts in your mouth".

thats my story and i'm sticking to it hehe.

p.s. i thought the scene where charlies last will and testament was read was brilliant, and if you watch the extras you see why....RIP buddy.

[–] Let_it_Be-1 12 years ago

If you are trying to compare milk chocolate, which this was NOT, then your argument would be valid. Dark chocolate doesn't have the fat so it,is harder. And melts in your mouth is definitely a relative term...t hey had never had chocolate before...it was a whole new experience, so our experience of growing up with milk chocolate in our mouths from infancy is waaaay different from having dark chocolate for the first time!

"That Barney Rubble, what an actor!!" -Night Shift

[–] kamy_22 12 years ago

To think that they spent millions of dollars on this movie and make mistakes!!

because it is "REAL" chocolate and not the FAKE milky stuff they package nowadays as chocolate. Also good quality chocolate melts at 36 degrees C -literally melts in your mouth - as the shopkeeper points out.

Dark chocolate always makes a "chocolate snap" sound that depends upon the cocoa quantity and quality. So they didnt make a mistake..

[–] parker-j7 7 years ago

What? An old cow hand can't enjoy a good chocolate bar?

[–] liscarkat (16548) 3 years ago

I've bought ordinary Hershey's chocolate bars from the grocery, where they were just sitting on an unrefrigerated shelf, opened them, and broken off a square with a sharp "snap!" So, the Foley work (or actual sound of Duvall biting off the chocolate) is plausible. That being said, this is probably the most trivial criticism of a movie I've ever read or heard.