top 5 western - Open Range (2003) Discussion

[–] noxcuse99 19 years ago

Keeping in the mind this is what I liked.

1)Tombstone
2)Wyatt Earp
3)Open Range
4)The Outlaw Josey Wales
5)True Grit

"Sure is a pretty day, for setting things right" Robert Duvall, Open Range

reply

[–] sheldonvh 19 years ago

My top 5 list is

1. The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
2. Unforgiven
3. Once upon a time in the West
4. Wyatt Earp
5. Open Range

reply

[–] Roach1039-1 19 years ago

1) and 2) is a tie between "The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly" and "Once Upon A Time in the West"
3)The Searchers
4) Rio Bravo
5) Unforgiven

Maybe that's all a family really is; a group of people who miss the same imaginary place.

reply

[–] gleetroy 17 years ago

1) Open Range

2) Once Upon A Time In the West

3) The Searchers

4) Tombstone

5) Stagecoach

reply

[–] bleeding_walls_420 13 years ago

1. Unforgiven
2. Tombstone
3. Open Range
4. Hang Em High
5. The Quick and the Dead

Not a huge western fan, but these are my favorites.

reply

[–] 13 years ago

[deleted]

[–] golfman00 17 years ago

1. The Cowboys

2. True Grit

3. Lonesome Dove

4. The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

5. The Outlaw Josey Wales

Honorable Mention: Once Upon a Time in The West, Open Range, The Searchers,

Silverado

reply

[–] grinstyle 17 years ago

Top five: 1.The Good The Bad And The Ugly 2.Open Range 3.Unforgiven 4.Tombstone 5.Once Upon A Time In The West And also mention: High Plains Drifter,A Fist Full Of Dollars,Sons Of Katie Elder and Big Jake.

reply

[–] alnc524 19 years ago

wow......anyone that puts this piece of crap movie in their Top 5 must have only SEEN 5 movies. I'm not even joking. It was an embarrassment that only Kevin Costner is capable of. How could any of the actors read those lines with a straight face? Total cornball garbage. Lame.

reply

[–] peglegpearl 19 years ago

To alnc524: You must have been the "star" that Costner beat out for the lead in this movie, the way you're bitchin'. Or were you beat out for the role of primary horse manure pile.

Here lies Les Moore-two slugs from a .44 - No less no more.

reply

[–] bullpen_1 11 years ago

Loved Open Range. The characters of Boss and Charlie played off one another perfectly, in my opinion. If there was one thing that didn't quite ring true about the film it would be this: no way a beautiful woman like Sue would have stayed single for so many years prior to Charlie coming in to her life.

You're right, no human being would stack books like this.

reply

[–] pointer_04 17 years ago

Have to agree with this whole-heartedly. Open Range suffered from flat characters and horrid dialogue. There are people think that Costner was good in this movie but honestly just about anyone could have pulled of such a crap of a character.

reply

[–] ristowge 16 years ago

1. The Terror of Tiny Town
2. Shane
3. High Noon
4. True Grit
5. Billy The Kid vs. Dracula
Harry Lime

reply

[–] tecknad 16 years ago

Keoma

once upon a time in the west

The great silence

proposition

butch cassidy

reply

[–] guybland-1 14 years ago

Overall, I found the movie a bit of a disappointment. While the story was powerful enough, the writing simply fell short. There were only outlines of characters, nothing substantial or memorable. Duvall is indeed a fine actor, and one who has proven himself time and again in the western genre (most notably Lonesome Dove). But not even he could compensate for the poor writing of this film. And Costner? A competent actor but certainly nothing to write home about.

reply

[–] stagebandman 13 years ago

You are entitled to your opinion. You are NOT entitled to debase someone else's opinion.

If we all liked the same movie, there'd only be one movie!

reply

[–] madmadrid 16 years ago

SHANE #1

reply

[–] id78 19 years ago

1 - Rio Bravo
2 - The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
3 - High Noon
4 - The Big Country
5 - Unforgiven

reply

[–] lastknown 19 years ago

I really can't believe you fellows think Open Range was a good movie. It was horrible.

Here are some of my favourite westerns: High Plains Drifter; For a few dollars more; The good, the bad and the ulgy; Lonsome Dove: The Outlaw Years; The Searchers; Once Upon a time in the west; The Man who shot Liberty Valance.

There are a lot of westerns I like which I can't remember the titles of.

reply

[–] peglegpearl 19 years ago

To lastknown: Horrible? You goob! Say ordinary, great or O.K., but don't say "horrible". Good Grief. What did you want, battleships?

Here lies Les Moore-two slugs from a .44 - No less no more.

reply

[–] rockycairns 17 years ago

in no order

Unforgiven
Wyatt Earp
Tombstone
Open Range
The Good the Bad and The Ugly

They had so much *beep* money you could build a house out of stacks of hundred dollar bills!!

reply

[–] taskren 17 years ago

Not saying ur wrong, but how could you have a lonesome Dove sequel, and not Lonesome Dove on your list. Lonesome Dove in itself is one of, if not the best, western of all time.

reply

[–] m-j-mooney 17 years ago

That's more like it, id78!

I think most of the previous posters have only been watching westerns for the last ten years or so - NOT the golden age, by a long stretch.

My list would change from day to day, but - as of right now - I'll go with:

1 High Noon
2 She Wore A Yellow Ribbon
3 For A Few Dollars More
4 The Magnificent Seven
5 Shane

Honorable mentions:

My Darling Clementine
The Searchers
The Big Country
Hombre
Winchester 73
The Gunfighter
The Long Riders
Stagecoach
3.10 To Yuma

Mike

reply

[–] nedeljkodjukic88 10 years ago

Great list, Mike! somehow people nowadays don't seem to realize nor understand the size and the meaning of the old westerns. But that popularity changes with time, I guess. Here are some I'd mention too:

The Ox-Bow incident
Soldier Blue
Once Upon a Time in the West
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
Tombstone
Dances with Wolves
One-eyed Jacks
Monte Walsh
The Wild Bunch
The Great Silence

But I'm yet to watch Stagecoach, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, The Treasure of Sierra Madre, She Wore a Yellow Ribbon...

reply

[–] Jimmy_Chitwood 19 years ago

1. Lonesome Dove (TV Movie)

2. The Good, The Bad & The Ugly

3. Tombstone

4. Quiggly Down Under

5. Once Upon A Time in the West

Honorable Mention: Open Range, Shanghai Noon, Silverado, Open Range, Pale Rider, Outlaw Josey Wales,

reply

[–] stfud 11 years ago

Unforgiven/The Searchers
Red River
My Darling Clementine
The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
Rio Bravo
The Outlaw Josey Wales
The Good The Bad and the Ugly
Open Range
She Wore a Yellow Ribbon

reply

[–] benedam-1 19 years ago

My Top 15, in no particular order (I could as well make a Top 20 or Top 30, but enough is enough ;o) ):

1. Once upon a Time in the West

2. Dances with Wolves

3. The Big Country

4. The Searchers

5. Rio Bravo

6. The Unforgiven

7. The Good, the Bad & the Ugly

8. The Shootist

9. The Sons of Katie Elder

10. Open Range

11. Chisum

12. The Man who shot Liberty Valance

13. Wyatt Earp

14. Tombstone

15. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid

... oh, I forgot to mention
High Noon,
The Treasure of the Sierra Madre,
The Magnificent Seven,
Hang 'em High,
For a Few Dollars (More)...

so much for the Top 20... ;o)

reply

[–] top4a 19 years ago

1. LONESOME DOVE! - Might be the best Western ever.

2. The Outlaw Josey Wales

3. Unforgiven

4. The Last Outlaw

5. The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

reply

[–] Rokol 19 years ago

1 Wild Bunch (can't believe nobody mentioned this!)
2 Man who shot Liberty Valance
3 Once upon a time in the west
4 Good, Bad and Ugly
5 The Searchers

reply

[–] beagle9 19 years ago

1) The Searchers
2) Lonesome Dove
3) The Unforgiven
4) Open Range
5) Quigley Down Under

reply

[–] benmilsom 17 years ago

You are absolutely spot on. Lonsome Dove is the finest, most epic western of all time. What fine taste you have.

reply

[–] marbleann 19 years ago

The Treasure of the Sierra Madre
High Noon
How the West was Won
The Searchers
Tombstone
The Gunfighter
The Magnificent 7

reply

[–] longhornbigg 19 years ago

wyat earp
tombstone
posse (just because it is origional)
shane (i cant believe nobody put this up here yet)
open range

reply

[–] persia-1 19 years ago

Agree with you about Shane, it's one of my favorites. Here's my list:

El Dorado
The Treasure of the Sierra Madre
Shane
High Noon
Tombstone
Dances With Wolves

Although it's not on my top favorites, "Open Range" is a pretty good movie. I really enjoyed it.

reply

[–] raynerchris 17 years ago

Good list

reply

[–] ricky-coombes 16 years ago

You know all these movie lists are great except most of the time its the same movies time and again. What I'd like to see is a western film list that has something I haven't seen before. I live in England and love the western genre, I'm even a member of a living history group (and before you ask, no I'm not over 50 and I don't have a long beard. let's face it most of them are). I'm a 25 year old lover of western movies. Unfortunatly it's also always the same westerns on TV. Heres a short list of westerns that I have been told are great but have never seen due to the fact that they never shown it on TV and haven't released it on DVD here:

The Treasure of Sierra Madre
The Train Robbers
Monte Walsh
Major Dundee
Blueberry
Across The Wide Missouri
Catlow
Cheyenne Autumn
Doc
The Naked Spur
Posse (Kirk Douglas)
The Left Handed Gun
They Died With Their Boots On
Tell Them Willy Boy Is Here
September Dawn
The Life And Times Of Judge Roy Bean
Grayeagle

And TV shows I would like to see:

Into The West
Centennial
Lonesome Dove: The Outlaw Years
Peacemakers

reply

[–] tommyuk 15 years ago

Treasure Of Sierra Madre isn't really a Western It's more in the Adventure category

reply

[–] Wakanohana 19 years ago

1) Red River
2) True Grit
3) Outlaw Josey Wales
4) Stagecoach (1939)
5) Fistful of Dollars

And a few more:
High Noon
The Magnificent Seven
Shane
The Searchers
Paint Your Wagon (Well, I liked it. So what?)

reply

[–] ATG6 (3000) 3 years ago

Great list. If I had to pick 5 of those:

Dances with Wolves
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
Open Range
Once Upon a Time in the West

A few other gems:

The Long Riders
My Name is Nobody
The Magnificent Seven
High Noon
True Grit

reply

[–] my_own_prison_in_paradise 19 years ago

1. The Good,the Bad and the Ugly
2. For A Few Dollars More
3. High Noon
4. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5. Unforgiven
6. Dances With Wolves
7. Once Upon A Time in the West
8. The Magnificent Seven
8. A Fistful of Dollars
9. The Outlaw Josey Wales
10.Mackenna's Gold

reply

[–] FilmFlaneur 19 years ago

Once Upon a Time in the West
The Searchers
The Wild Bunch
Johnny Guitar
Silver Lode

An age in which machine-gun editing has replaced the cinematic equivalent of perfect pitch

reply

[–] scotchyscotchscotch 19 years ago

1. Shane
2. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
3. Open Range
4. Unforgiven
5. The Shootist (Very underated!)

Just missing the top 5 are:

6. Wyatt Earp
7. The Outlaw Josey Wales
8. Hombre
9. Pale Rider
10. Dances with Wolves

reply

[–] sean_p1206 14 years ago

No Order:

Once Upon A Time In The West

The Assassination of the Outlaw jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford

The Proposition

For A Few Dollars More

Unforgiven

Hon. Mention:

Deadwood

reply

[–] kroberteaton 19 years ago

In no particular order and just as they come off the top of my head (NOT to be taken as better than many others I could think, but I'll just STOP at FIVE...)

The Fastest Gun Alive
The Gunfighter
Man on Horseback
The Magnificent Seven
Open Range(as good a western as has ever been made as far as I'm concerned...)

Here's ANOTHER FIVE that could've come to mind earlier...
The Big Country
Broken Arrow
Wonderful Country
The Tin Star
Wichita (To me, a better film about Earp than EITHER Wyatt Earp, Tombstone OR My Darling Clementine.)

Then there's
Shane
The Tall Men
Lonely are the Brave
Will Penny
and
High Noon (One of the best westerns - and films - ever made.)

I could probably do it again (and again...) but I've got a show to go watch...

Later...

"Principles only mean something if you stick to them when they're INconvenient"

reply

[–] 19 years ago

[deleted]

[–] aenimatow21 19 years ago

1. The Good the Bad and the Ugly
2. Once opon a time in the west
3. Dances with wolves
4. Unforgiven
5. For a few dollars more

reply

[–] michaeltrout 19 years ago

(1) The Good, the Bad & the Ugly
(2) Tombstone
(3) Unforgiven
(4) Butch Cassidy & the Sundance Kid
(5) Fistful of Dollars
(6) High Noon
(7) For a Few Dollars More
(8) Open Range (but only because of the fight scenes, the script is otherwise awful)
(9) Once Upon a Time in the West
(10) Wild Wild West (not really, of course, just making sure you're still paying attention)

reply