Are you kidding me?


There's no way the characters in this movie are 12-13 years old. Disney must be on crack or something.

reply

i know! I hate how on tv a 15 year old person will be in 6th grade! or a 9 year old will be in 8th grade! AAAAAGGGGGGGGGHHHHHH!

reply

Do you have a reason for your pointless rant? Are they too old? Too young? Or are you "soawesome" that you don't need to justify your accusations?

I don't remember how old they were supposed to be, but if they're supposed to be 12-13, then the casting is pretty much spot on...

"The difference between stupidity and genius is that genius has its limits." - Albert Einstein

reply

Way to bring my pen name into the argument, "SilentJay". Should I somehow find a way to incorporate yours into here as well?

Do you really think there's a point to anything on the IMDb message boards, "SilentJay"? No. It's just to discuss movies. And if you feel that the casting is spot on, you really need a reality check on what 12-13 year olds look like. First of all, the 12-13 year old guys havent even hit puberty, which the guys in this movie definitely have, if not they've finished it. 12-13 year old girls are rail skinny and overly made up to try and look older. Although Lindsay Lohan is rail skinny now, she wasn't then; she actually had curves and big boobs. The only one that I think could maybe pass for a 14-year-old is Brenda Song.

Is this justification enough for you, "SilentJay"?

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0383574/board/nest/47738289
Elizabeth and Jack analysis.

reply

Should I somehow find a way to incorporate yours into here as well?
Please do. Although I strongly doubt that you'll be able to, since you've already failed miserably on your three attempts thus far.

Also - where the heck do you live where 13-year-olds look the way you describe them? I'm guessing in some poverty stricken third world country, where kids develop later due to malnourishment? 'Cause otherwise you seem to be completely oblivious to things happening around you...

"The difference between stupidity and genius is that genius has its limits." - Albert Einstein

reply

Whaaaaaaaaaat? They were supposed to be 12 years old???

The difference between fiction and reality? Fiction has to make sense. --Tom Clancy

reply

[deleted]

Well Lindsey Lohan was 15 going on 16 when this movie aired.

These things aren't unheard of. Raven Symone was about 17-18 when That's So Raven aired while her character, Raven Baxter was like 14.

Christy Carlson Romano was like 15-17 and playing a middle school girl on Even Stevens.

reply

No, the costume designer was on crack.

reply