which ship would win

In that same episode there was an interesting ship with the power to erase stuff from history. So one shot from that ship and any other mentioned in this thread would disapear not only from present but from the past too making it unexistence.

"I think there is a difference between a work of art and an Oscar." Roger Corman

Lets go ahead and throw in the Covenant ships from Halo.

-------------------------------------


(-_-)

Obviously the andromeda would fail completely. No sheilds = dead ship. All you need is to make a nanite gun, releases nanites that kill harpers nanites then begin to eat away at the hull. Also they replicate and are unkillable except by other nanites, as by the rules of nanites (and no "emp" bs). Of course, it would take years for nanites to do that type of dammage but still.

Replicators then, thats a great enemy for andromeda.

The problem with Shields, however, is that ships seem to suffer internal damage even WITH them on (and more than just the inertial shock).


Anchient, Ori, or even Anubis should be able to beat Andromeda... Sheilds will do that you know.

As for trek? Nope, they got nothing. Trek ships are big, slow (you'd think they'd invent "impulse warp" already. Jump into warp for .0001s and rejump over and over) and mostly only have forward attack cannons. There's a small poop chute on enterprise, but not much else... get above or below it and you can take the ship down regardless of firepower (remember, damaging the sheilds damages the ship). And since the ships are so DAMN SLOW, a manuverable ship like andromeda, there's nothing that the feds can do.

Let alone andromeda has fighters... what do you think a few shuttle pods are going to do? Seriously, Star Trek: TNG is awful. Enterprise is not a warship, it's not even close to one... the Defiant is an assault ship, but still not a warship.

And the defiant is still just a tiny little assault ship, and andromeda has TURRETS (Finally, LOGIC, big ships SHOULD have turrets, like the Flash Gordan turret barrage, not be frontal assault) No chance what so ever.

But take this into consideration, the commonwealth built how many of those ships? And HOW BADLY DID THEY GET BEAT? Thats right, they lost, andromeda lost... and a thousand year old ship is top of the line a thousand years later :p

[deleted]

The Defiant could easily crush Andromeda, as could any Enterprise or one of the Stargate Earth vessels with Ancient tech. As Andromeda has no shield, it has no way to stop them from beaming stuff aboard, like antimatter warheads.

In the case of the Defiant, it could decloak in transporter range and end the fight before it started.