MovieChat Forums > The Body (2001) Discussion > What is the problem?

What is the problem?


After the resurrection, surely it was only his spirit that ascended into heaven!

That someone then put his earthly remains back in the tomb doesn't change anything, as far as I can see.

On the contrary, his bones could be used to prove, what is written in the gospels is true.

reply

It is a fundamental teaching of the Roman Catholic Church that Jesus "rose from the dead", that is he was dead and then became alive again, and then later "ascended into Heaven". This means he went up to Heaven under his own steam, physical body and all. So there could not have been a body left behind.

The Church teaches that this event prefigures the "Resurrection of the Body" for all humankind. After the "Second Coming" of Jesus, when he comes back to earth in all his glory, this existence as we know it will come to an end, and ALL human bodies that have died throughout history will be resurrected and reunited with their souls. Yes, really, you'll get your body back! Of course, if you're in Hell it won't be much consolation to you; it'll just be something extra which God can use to torture you with for all eternity. Also, it won't be much consolation if you were born with a terrible deformity, or died at birth, or in the womb as a day old embryo! Or are as ugly as I am.

One further point: the physical body of Mary, the mother of Jesus, also went to Heaven in its full physical entirety. In fact the Church teaches that she never died at all. When her time came she was "assumed into Heaven", that is she was taken up to Heaven by angels alive. The Church celebrates this event by the Feast of the Assumption. So there are two physical human bodies in Heaven at this moment, Jesus and Mary.

So, all this means that if the fully-authenticated body of Jesus was found it would undercut the basic teaching of the Church and throw into doubt the whole Catholic faith.

reply

Both Christian and Muslim resurrection are bodily resurrection. "Spirit" is immortal, it doesn't die nor resurrect.

reply

Because that body was raised again. It became immortal flesh. Jesus was God manifest in the flesh. The fullness of the Godhead dwells in Jesus bodily.
If the body was still there, that would mean Jesus was still there. Jesus was the God-Man. Fully God and Fully Man. He is the express image of the Father. That body is the only person in the Godhead.

reply

We are in the Easter season. We celebrate Christ's death and resurrection.
If he had not died and rose again, he would be like the other dead prophets of the world's religions. However, he did rise from the grave and is our Lord and Savior. His bones are not here. That body was raised by the Holy Spirit.
Emmanuel will make his Second return to get his people. Be Ready.

reply