MovieChat Forums > In the Cut (2003) Discussion > The Piano or In The Cut?

The Piano or In The Cut?


Which does everyone think is the better Jane Campion film?

reply

I prefer In the Cut although I like both a lot.

I'm a fountain of blood
In the shape of a girl

reply

No contest. Definitely The Piano, although I find Mark Ruffalo much sexier than Harvey Keitel.

reply

Piano was much better.

Therefore we may call that art true at which does not seem to be art."

reply

Lol What a question. The Piano wins hands down. In the Cut is a terrible film. It looks good and has its moments but truly it's not a good film. The Piano is the best film she's ever done. If you've not seen Angel at My Table, you should.

I'll tell you in another life when we are both cats.

reply

Lol What a question. The Piano wins hands down. In the Cut is a terrible film. It looks good and has its moments but truly it's not a good film. The Piano is the best film she's ever done. If you've not seen Angel at My Table, you should.

I'll tell you in another life when we are both cats.

reply

Of course In the Cut, The Piano is extremely stupid film.

reply