MovieChat Forums > Requiem for a Dream (2000) Discussion > isn't this movie just an extended music ...

isn't this movie just an extended music video?


Don't get me wrong, I like this movie, but I can't help but feel that at the end of the day, it really just is an extended music video.

What I mean by this, is that as well shot, well acted, and emotionally haunting this film is, there's really not much in the way of substance to it. The film is about addiction, but it never really delves much deeper into the subject beyond "life sucks, so let's get high".

It's not exactly unusual for real-life addicts to have this sorta mentality, but this idea has already been explored in multiple films prior to this (most notably, Trainspotting) and Aronofsky's movie doesn't really go in any sort of different direction.

It doesn't make the film any less dramatically effective, but it does, for me anyway, stop it from being great. I still feel as though the movie works overall but more due to Aronofsky's style and flair as a filmmaker as opposed to there being a legitimately great story to tell in the first place. The script is honestly merely servicable and feels like it was written solely the way just to show off visual set pieces.

It's why ultimately, I feel as though Requiem for a Dream is sorta like an extended music video.

Anyone else feel this way?

Discuss...

reply

I sort of agree with what you're saying.
Unfortunately, I am an addict, am friends with addicts, and I can tell you that this movie really hits home with me, at least. So much so that I am afraid to show it to my friends because I do not want to send them into some depressive introspective spiral that results in more drug abuse.
I have revisited this film recently, and have actually gone to sleep with it playing in the background, and the sound of it alone is pleasing.
To call it an extended music video is a valid assessment, because the music and pacing are truly integral to the final product. But I think that the point still gets across--drugs are bad, yada yada...
But what gets me with this film is how it depicts the mind-state of an addict--which I can relate to all too well. And how some addicts can fall victim without any intention of doing so (Ellen Burstyn's character--I mean, all she did was trust a doctor to help her lose weight...because of a dream of being on television... And I used to think that my dealers were also my friends).
To chase a dream...but to think that drugs--that getting high--will help you achieve that dream, or make reality easier... That's the sad part, because it really does happen to people. And the consequences of following such a path are so dire...is it really worth it?

Another great film (and novel) that tackles similar themes is A Scanner Darkly. Very informative regarding the composition of a drug-addled mind.

reply

[deleted]

I've never really agreed with the style over substance criticism for movies. I think there's a place for everything. What you're saying about it is true, but I still think a great "extended music video" can be appreciated as much as anything else. If Aronofsky felt like he had to include more character development or dialogue to seem like there were more layers, maybe it doesn't turn out as great. The quality is what's important.

reply