MovieChat Forums > Notting Hill (1999) Discussion > Disabled wife, upstairs bedroom

Disabled wife, upstairs bedroom


This will probably seem a very petty, nit-picky critique, but a loud false note for me was the Gina McKee character is in a wheelchair, she has a modest-sized, comfortable looking house and her bedroom is upstairs. Her husband must carry her up there every night, and I suppose downstairs every morning. I have worked with a lot of disabled people and that depiction is ridiculous. First thing every person ending up in a wheelchair after an injury/accident does is get his/her home modified for convenience. That means everything is on a level the person in the chair can reach independently. So the rooms the disabled person must access--bedroom, bathroom, kitchen, dining room, TV room, whatever other room is necessary--will be on the first level that's either flush with the outside entrance or has a lift or a ramp to access it. The absolute LAST thing a wheelchair-user wants is to have a room he needs to go into require him to be carried up stairs to get to. Same with going back down. A two-level house might have a chair lift that carries the disabled person upstairs, but usually the simplest thing is to redesign the living space to have all rooms the wheelchair-user needs to get into on one level. It might be necessary occasionally for him or her to be carried by someone over stairs, etc., but that wouldn't be in the person's home. It's important, and really necessary, for a person in a wheelchair to be able to get around his/her own home completely independently. It's simply impractical for a wheelchair-user to live in a home that requires another person to carry him up stairs. It's also a serious safety hazard.

This is even more true for anyone living in the UK. The government provides a great deal more assistance to the disabled for home modification than the U.S. does for its disabled citizens.

I guess the movie had it this way to highlight how very much in love the married couple was that the husband would carry the wife up to bed every night...but it bugged me because it's so far outside the realm of the real world.

reply

In the back of the shot you can at least see the runners for the stairlift

reply

Yup. I believe I saw that too. I think he just wanted to carry her up that night.

reply

i didn't catch the stair life but this was also an issue if you saw 'the theory of everything'. they were lucky to have a bedroom on the first floor, but there were stairs EVERYWHERE in that house, and i've actually see interviews by Jane Hawking saying handicap accessibility is horrific in the UK. all the homes are like townhomes and stairs everywhere, so having to be carried didn't surprise me in the least.

reply

I agree about the accessibility in English homes. Lucky for my husband's grandmother, she moved into a small bungalow that does not have any stairs as she got older. It was certainly praised as a new style of home for England. We got to go through my husband's childhood home and I couldn't believe how small it was. He and his brothers room was the crawl space in the roof, his mum had to make the bed from the ladder. I can understand why they wanted to move to Australia...

reply

I took it to show the husband's devotion to her.
When my mom came home in a wheelchair, she had to move downstairs. We also had to take out a door or two and build a ramp outside.
Reality vs romantic movie

reply

They already lived in that house prior to her accident. It's not like they stupidly bought a two-story house, knowing that she was handicapped.

reply

It was also said the accident was 18 months prior.

reply