MovieChat Forums > South Park (1997) Discussion > Scott Tenorman Must Die = The Greatest E...

Scott Tenorman Must Die = The Greatest Episode

posted 8 years ago by valkor-1
23 replies | jump to latest

Definitely a perfect episode, followed closely by:

Woodland Critter Christmas
Fun with Weapons
Make Love not Warcraft
Ike and the school teacher (Niceee) Whatever that episode is called

My top 5

[–] Whip-duicide 7 years ago

I enjoy Save Willzyax (however you spell it), the gay fish and the taco *beep* ice cream episode, Cartman being a somali pirate captain and the one where Butters becomes a pimp.

Least those 5 come to mind right now. Casual viewer however.

[–] patdog12241982 7 years ago

'Free Willzyx', 'Fishsticks' & 'CANCELLED', 'FATBEARD' & 'BUTTERS BOTTOM B!+C#' are what you've named (I knew most off-hand, checked Willzyx's spelling, otherwise... ) My buddies & I have said that 'Broadway Bro Down' is the *PERFECT* episode:

1)relatively self-contained
2) pokes fun @ things that will be relevant &/or memorably BAD long enough to give the episode 'legs'
3)the 'twist' makes sense within the story
4) The final joke/self-promotion is 'in your face' & 'tongue-in-cheek' @ the same time instead of beating over the head w/ it (only COULD have been funnier if they had said "Book of Mormon? Those losers can't write for $#!+")

I fell asleep during INCEPTION BUT I FEEL like I still saw it!

[–] DeadandBuried81 7 years ago

It was the awakening of Cartman's true dark side. Great episode, I love how Cartman brings it up when he is sitting with Bart Simpson in Cartoon Wars.

www.thecultofhorror.blogspot.com

[–] Electrical1 7 years ago

Scott Tenorman Must Die is undoubtedly a great and iconic episode, but IMO is a bit overrated.

[–] patdog12241982 7 years ago

Its 'over rated' in that its probably played too much even for its own perfection, yes?
I'd like to see 'Night of the Living Homeless', 'Fantastic Easter Special' & 'Bloody Mary' make the rounds more often, though honestly I'd also like the Super Best Friends episode to air again & have 201 uncensored so...

I fell asleep during INCEPTION BUT I FEEL like I still saw it!

[–] theauxphou 7 years ago

You're right, that is a great episode. Probably my favourite.

[–] jackbnimbleharvardblue 7 years ago

Scott Tenorman Must Die is the greatest for me but sometimes I feel these epsiodes are funnier
'Butters Bottom B'
'The Succubus'
'Cartman's Mom Is Still A Dirty Slut'
'Make Love Not Warcraft'
'Dances With Smurfs'
'Go God Go I and II'
'Krazy Kripples'

[–] sooperklew 7 years ago

I nominate 'Creme Fraiche' and 'Grounded Vindaloop'

[–] patdog12241982 7 years ago

I saw creme fraiche on a menu @ a restaurant & had to order it (I thin it was on french fries or potato skins!)

I fell asleep during INCEPTION BUT I FEEL like I still saw it!

[–] quantumphyzx 7 years ago

I'm pretty sure I'm alone in this, but one of my favorite episodes is Jewbilee. Seeing holographic Moses demand macaroni necklaces for appeasement gets me everytime lol

[–] MyCousinMose (86) 7 years ago

My top 5 in no particular order -

Raisins
The 1%
City Sushi
Canada on Strike
Good Times with Weapons

(Scott Tenorman Must Die didn't make the cut but it was a hard choice, definitely next on my list)
Oh and somebody said that they don't think Butters getting hit in the eye with a ninja star is funny, I definitely respect that opinion. It probably shouldn't be funny, but my gosh I laugh so hard every time I watch it.

[–] Mint Berry Crunch (345) 7 years ago

Whenever I show South Park to someone for the first time, I show them Butters Very Own Episode. That usually hooks them.

The most I ever laughed was Good Times with Weapons when Butters got hit in the eye and the craziness that ensues.