How is Disco different?


How is Disco different than clubbing? Obviously, the music will be different. But their lives seemed pretty much like mine now. I go clubbing every weekend.

reply

Disco just meant a mix of like-sounding rhythmic bass-oriented music, danced to by polyester fashioned gay-looking guys.

The anomaly was, as stupid and shallow it may have been (musically/socially) it was very significant for about five years in the radio/rec./club business until it vanished as quickly as it appeared.

Disco is primarily thought of as Eastern, urban, gay, drug oriented, hedonistic, and appreciated much more by women (and Europeans) than (straight) men. Dancing to Donna Summer or the Village people couldn't have made it at any other time.


reply

Disco, despite being primarily electronic, had a level of organicness and exoticness to it, and melody. The krapola they play in "clubs" today has none of that...you need to be numbed on Ex or something else in order to dance to that hip hop/trance/house garbage.
And disco was a fad that was around for about four years, and then people grew tired of it, grew up, or moved on to another genre (punk, rock n roll, or New Wave). Hip hop/trance/house has been dragged out for nearly a decade....and it's getting worse. I thought we'd hit rock bottom a few years ago with Fergie's London Bridge and Justin's Sexyback...but sadly the spiral is still moving down. Rock and roll needs to drop another bomb--this time on hip hop and house. Or people are just so dumbed down and have such low expectations, they don't care what is played. But if anything with melody would be played at these clubs, they'd probably have seizures.
Honestly I wish they'd blow up hip hop/house CDs and records in a stadium as they did with disco records. Compared to hip hop and trance, disco music is not disposable. I'd venture to bet that clubbers today do not play the krap they hear in clubs inside their own homes---that wasn't the case with disco. In 2009, people still enjoy hearing Chic and Donna Summer (at parties, weddings, etc). Twenty years from now, will people be craving to hear London Bridge and Sexyback? Not bloody likely.

Dude means nice guy. Dude means a regular sort of person.

reply

And disco was a fad that was around for about four years...
Love Train by the O'Jays (the song on the subway car at the end), arguably the first true disco song, was released in December 1972 and cracked the Top 40 at the end of January 1973. I don't know about New York, where this film is set, but out here in the provinces (I live in Arizona), disco was pushed off the airwaves by the growing popularity of punk/new wave in 1978 or 1979 and the continuing popularity of country rock/southern boogie, heavy metal, and progressive/arena rock. Disco was then pushed out of the bars in 1980 by the mass conversion of clubs to a country format in response to Urban Cowboy.

~~Bayowolf
There's a difference between being frank... and being dick.

reply

Disposable is the right word. Listening to the music & seeing the pictures, there's an element of glamour to disco. We think of it as "tacky" because it included a lot of lower-class people trying to make themselves look fancy. People were TRYING.

House/techno/rave were more fratty. Very common to see a guy in a tank top, jeans & baseball cap. And those who did dress up are mostly just being campy. Nothing wrong with that, it's just left no legacy.

reply

The significance of disco (the "scene", not the music style) isn't that it's different than anything today, but that it was different from what had come before. Did you watch the movie? The characters discuss the significance of the movement very well.

Throughout the 20th century in America there was always a nightclub "scene" where people would go to clubs, eat, dance, and socialize; except during the 1950's and 1960's when a series of factors ended this phenomenon (affordable home audio equipment moved the business model toward record sales, post war families were too busy making a baby boom to go out to night clubs, black music fragmented audiences). Disco, in the '70s, was the first nightclub scene in America since WW2. It was the start of your "clubbing" scene today.

reply

Excellent observation. My $0.02.

The main part of disco is dancing -- not just do-your-thing jerk to the music type dancing, but also hold hands and lead your partner with a pattern of steps type dancing. (While the music in the movie was genuine, the dance was not quite.) And here lies the downfall of disco -- the men were under tremendous pressure to be good dancers, to make the ladies feel fun and excitement and not to look ridiculous. They became uncomfortable and self-conscious, and felt being measured. The steps were not easy to pick up just by watching but there was no one to ask. Your lady friend was all polite and smiling but was obvious having a lot more fun when the other guy was twirling her this way and that. You are a cool guy but your movements are clumsy on the dance floor. Your confident plummets. Disco sucks.

reply

People have always gone to dance clubs since at least the 1920s and probably before that. The music just changed. All you rock purists out there should be glad to know that the original Rock-n-Roll from the 1950s was, in effect, dance music and a reaction against the staid establishment music of the time.

reply

You had to be there to understand.

reply