awful movie


i go to Catholic High School (don't get me started), and we watched this in class and now i have to write a paper on it, but it was so horrendously bad that i don't know what to write

reply

This movie is one of the greats and one of my all time favorites. You must be too young to understand. Why didn't you like it?

What these women went through was a living hell. (It is a true story.) Imagine the horrors of what they had to endure. They were imprisoned against their will. They had no rights. This was at a time when women had almost no power anyway and what little identity they had was stripped from them. They were starved, beaten, raped, and generally tortured and treated like dogs. They feared every living moment. There was no communication with the outside world - no cell phones, GPS or internet. No one even knew of their plight.

The only thing they had to hold onto was each other and the music they had inside. They had to learn it in secret. It gave them the will to survive. Many didn't make it and died a horrible death in that Godforsaken place. It was the only thing they had to hold onto that the Japanese could not take away from them. Music is a powerful thing, the harmonic connection between all living things. It gave them dignity and gave them hope and was the thing that saved (some of) their lives.

Also, the performances were wonderful by some of the greatest actresses of our time. I'd say do some research about the real women of this story. Then try watching it again with an open mind.


"Whoever you are, I have always depended on the kindness of strangers."

reply

Why, Ms Blanche, I do like your response!
:)

I watched this awhile back and I really loved the vocal arrangement of Dvorak's 9th Symphony. When you mentioned music as something which kept the women going, it also reminded me of Wladyslaw Szpilman who, even amidst that horrendous period, had music which ultimately saved him (yes, I know it was a lot more complicated than that).

"Arrrggghhhhh!!!!! Jonathan!!!! These cheap phones keep on shattering!!!!"

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

The sheer ignorance exposed in your moronic post is borderline absurd. The film is an awful portrayal of life in POW camps; barely even scratching the surface of what actually occurred.

Of course this is a serious subject and of course it involves a lot of human suffering, however, the fact still remains that this film does no justice to it whatsoever.

I’d also like to add that this film was recognized as an awful representation by a high school student, proving how mentally challenged you are.

reply

Agreed!

reply

I guess this just proves that both public and parochial schools are now turning out the same brainless airheads who have no ability to think about nothing more important than what color thong to wear the next morning...

reply

amen to the last two comments. i go to a public high school and i loved the movie. i am so happy to have to write a paper on it, it was such a good film!

reply

Thanks for the great AMEN! I loved the movie in spite of some of the grossness. I was born not too long after the WWII (1951) So I do relate kind of. I am a former musician, no longer playing due to hearing loss, but then Beethoven was deaf so go figure.Need to know the actor's name, please for the Missionary lady who assisted with the Choir?

reply

[deleted]