MovieChat Forums > FairyTale: A True Story (1997) Discussion > Not exactly a "true story"

Not exactly a "true story"


The "true story" this is supposedly based on is nothing more than a prank two young girls pulled in the late 1800s. All they did was photograph themselves with the "fairies" they found, which were later found out to be nothing more than story book cut-outs glued to hat pins.


--------
"Y'all are SO wack."
"Wiggity-wack?"
"Nope, just regular-type."

reply

[deleted]

Why isn't Mel Gibson properly credited in the actor's list in the movie? (didn't he want to show his name?!)

reply

Why isn't Mel Gibson properly credited in the actor's list in the movie? (didn't he want to show his name?!)

reply

Well, Fairytale was made by his production company, Icon Productions, so perhaps he thought it'd be a bit self-indulgent to give himself a credit for a role that's (presumably; I haven't seen the film) not much more than a cameo, in a movie where he's the "boss", as it were.

reply

[deleted]

Originally posted by eStreetBeat:
[Decades later, they both] admitted unequivocally that they had fabricated the images but, to their dying days, they insisted that they had actually seen [the] fairies... they had tried to represent what they had actually seen.


I am a little confused about this part: If Elsie and Frances had tried to "represent" the fairies as they had seen them, then why did Elsie not draw them from memory? Both girls stated that they had seen the Beck fairies numerous times, I would assume on a weekly, or even daily basis, and they had ample time to observe the darling things up to the point where they almost ignored the fairies. If that was the case, then why did Elsie need to trace her fairies from drawings by Arthur Shepperson from the Princess Mary's Gift Book?

--------------
Everyone dies but not everyone gets to live.

reply

They admitted they were fake, but they never denied seeing the fairies.

"Are you my mummy?..."

reply

"They admitted they were fake, but they never denied seeing the fairies."

Wrong! Only Frances claimed this.

reply

Maybe the fairies were "fake but accurate" -- like Dan Rather's memos about George W. Bush's 1972 miltary records that were re-created in 2004.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

But it is "true" in the sense that it is not a created fictional storyline.

reply